Don't Buy a Crude Oil Index ETF, Buy This Energy Stock Instead

Editor's note: It's one thing to understand specific strategies for investing in oil. But the most profitable ideas come from having the global perspective of a true industry insider. That's exactly what Dr. Kent Moors' premium subscribers get. Learn more here

oil index etfMany investors are looking to buy a crude oil index ETF to profit from oil's rise throughout 2015.

WTI oil prices are up 7% this year. And we expect oil prices to continue climbing in 2015.

The expected oil price climb has made crude oil index ETF investing increasingly popular. The Wall Street Journal reported about $6 billion was invested in oil ETFs in the first quarter alone.

But many crude oil index ETFs have one major problem right now that many investors aren't aware of...

Why You Shouldn't Invest in a Crude Oil Index ETF

The problem is known as "contango."

Contango happens when prices are higher than the spot price of oil.

You see, many of these oil ETFs track futures contracts rather than the spot price. When there's a price gap between the price of the expiring contract, and the new futures contract, the fund has to buy contracts at the higher price. That means the fund is constantly buying high and selling low.

What Is Contango?

Contango refers to the situation when the oil futures contract trades at a higher price than the spot price of oil.

During periods of contango, people are willing to pay more for a commodity in the future than the actual expected price of the commodity. This can occur when people are willing to pay a premium for a commodity's future delivery, rather than paying for the storage of the commodity.

This can be a problem for ETFs that track the price of oil using oil futures contracts.

When there's a price gap between the price of the expiring contract and the new futures contract, the fund is consistently buying contracts at a higher price. Essentially, it's constantly buying high and selling low on the futures contracts.

For example, if the new futures contract is $2 higher than the expiring one, investors will encounter what is called a "negative roll yield" of $2. Again, the ETF is buying high and selling low to track the price of oil month to month.

Contango typically occurs during periods of unusually low prices and high production.

The last time this happened to oil prices was the "supercontango" during the 2008 financial crisis. Back then, oil tanker ships stockpiled millions of barrels of crude oil off the coasts of the Gulf of Mexico, England, and other major production areas. The spread between spot prices and futures prices 12 months later was more than $23 a barrel for WTI.

Any spread between the spot price and futures price can cause crude oil index ETFs to miss profits.

This chart shows an example of contango at work...

The chart tracks price movements in the WTI spot price of oil compared to the U.S. Oil Fund LP (NYSE Arca: USO).

oil index etfsThe United States Oil Fund is one of the most popular oil index ETFs on the market. Financial Times reported that more than $2 billion was invested in it in 2014.

But USO misses out on gains when the market is in contango. From 2009 to 2011, WTI prices increased more than 115% while USO only gained 34%.

USO also endures harsher tax treatment. ETFs that track oil futures contracts face higher taxes than other funds due to their regulation by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC). That means investors receive higher taxes as well.

While a crude oil index ETF offers some returns, there are better profit opportunities in the energy sector.

The best oil stocks to buy during contango periods are midstream master limited partnerships (MLPs). These are the firms that own assets like pipelines and storage facilities.

Money Morning Resource Specialist Peter Krauth recommends one with more than 14 terminals in strategic locations across the United States...

The Best Alternative to a Crude Oil Index ETF

A great midstream investment right now is World Point Terminals LP (NYSE: WPT).

World Point owns and operates storage facilities for crude oil, jet fuel, and liquid asphalt. Its terminals are scattered across the East Coast, Gulf Coast, and Midwestern United States.

[epom key="ddec3ef33420ef7c9964a4695c349764" redirect="" sourceid="" imported="false"]

As of early March, the MLP has 12.8 million barrels of storage capacity across its more than two dozen facilities. Its widespread locations allow the company to provide easy access to transportation near demand markets and export hubs.

"I wouldn't be surprised to see shares gain 40% to 50% over the next six months as the market comes to realize that production cuts will soon kick in and demand isn't about to fall off a cliff," Krauth explained. "In fact, I expect demand to get somewhat more robust as retail, commercial, and industrial consumers find ways to use more at these lower prices."

Yahoo! Finance has a one-year target estimate of $20.75. That's 22.1% higher than WPT stock's current price of $17 a share.

The Bottom Line: Investors are throwing money at oil index ETFs to profit from the oil price rebound. But today's contango environment causes these funds to miss out on gains due to the gap between the spot price of oil and futures price. Instead, investors should focus on midstream companies because they stay profitable as long as the oil keeps flowing. World Point Terminals LP is a healthy long-term buy as demand picks up throughout the year.

What are your thoughts on crude oil index ETF investing? Talk to us on Twitter at @AlexMcGuire92 and @moneymorning.

Make 2015 Your Wealthiest Year Yet... It just takes four easy steps to get started. We tell you what they are in our money-making guide for 2015. You'll get the three bad investing habits to dump immediately and the single most effective strategy to maximize returns. Plus, you'll find out five stocks that will get you started on the road to wealth...

Related Articles: