Share This Article

Facebook LinkedIn
Twitter Reddit
Print Email
Pinterest Gmail
Yahoo
Money Morning
×
  • Invest
    • Best Stocks to Buy
    • Stock Forecasts
    • Stocks to Sell Now
    • Stock Market Predictions
    • Technology Stocks
    • Best REITs to Buy Now
    • IPO Stocks
    • Penny Stocks
    • Dividend Stocks
    • Cryptocurrencies
    • Cannabis Investing
    • Angel Investing
  • Trade
    • How to Trade Options
    • Best Trades to Make Now
    • Options Trading Strategies
    • Weekly Trade Recommendations
  • Retire
    • Income Investing Guide
    • Retirement Articles
  • More
    • Money Morning LIVE
    • Special Investing Reports
    • Our ELetters
    • Our Premium Services
    • Videos
    • Meet Our Experts
    • Profit Academy
Login My Member Benefits Archives Research Your Team About Us FAQ
  • Invest
    • Best Stocks to Buy
    • Stock Forecasts
    • Stocks to Sell Now
    • Stock Market Predictions
    • Technology Stocks
    • Best REITs to Buy Now
    • IPO Stocks
    • Penny Stocks
    • Dividend Stocks
    • Cryptocurrencies
    • Cannabis Investing
    • Angel Investing
    ×
  • Trade
    • How to Trade Options
    • Best Trades to Make Now
    • Options Trading Strategies
    • Weekly Trade Recommendations
    ×
  • Retire
    • Income Investing Guide
    • Retirement Articles
    ×
  • More
    • Money Morning LIVE
    • Special Investing Reports
    • Our ELetters
    • Our Premium Services
    • Videos
    • Meet Our Experts
    • Profit Academy
    ×
  • Subscribe
Enter stock ticker or keyword
×
Join 100,000+ Like-Minded Investors Today
Twitter
Tags: Martin Hutchinson

Credit Default Swaps: A $50 Trillion Problem

By , Money Morning • April 2, 2008

View Comments

Start the conversation

By Martin Hutchinson
Contributing Editor

Of all the really bad ideas that have infested the finance business in the last 30 years, the most dangerous is probably the credit default swap (CDS).

CDS is almost a brand new investment vehicle, but the market is already 20 times its size in 2000. The principal amount of CDS outstanding equals $50 trillion, or more than three times the U.S. Gross Domestic Product and bigger than all the U.S. credit markets put together. And the CDS has been a huge source of "financial engineering" profits, both for Wall Street and the hedge fund community over the last few years.

The first true credit default swap was carried out as late as 1995, although various types of credit protection derivatives existed earlier. Its structure is similar to an ordinary interest rate or currency swap transaction, and the CDS market is covered by the International Swaps and Derivatives Association Inc.

Story continues below...

Under a CDS, a bank originates loan to a company. A second bank (or other financial institution) can agree to cover the credit risk for the loan, by agreeing to make payment to originating bank if the company defaults on the original loan. The originating bank pays a small insurance premium to the second bank for assuming the risk of the loan.

Typically, payments under a CDS would only be triggered by the company's failure to pay interest or principal on its debts due to bankruptcy or some other severe liquidity issue. But there are a host of intermediate or special cases that will doubtless provoke lawsuits when something goes wrong (CDS being a new market, it is by no means "recession-proof").

Credit default swaps were sold to the world as hedging transactions. Investors were told that they were simply transfers of risk, so that banks that made loans could transfer credit risks to insurance companies, which did not make loans directly, or to foreign banks that could not easily make loans in the U.S. market.

And if an originating bank sells its loan exposure only once, and sells it to a financial firm of undoubtedly solid credit, the CDS does indeed act as a hedge for the originating bank; it transfers the company's credit risk from the bank to the financial firm that bought its CDS.

But the product did not work as advertised.

Enter the Traders

Salesmen and traders took over, and expanded the volume far beyond what was required for hedging.

After all, bonuses depend on the volume of business. Therefore, bank traders sold the credit risk of a loan not just once, but as many as 10 times. And they sold it not to solid banks and insurance companies, but to three solid banks, one solid insurance company, three dodgy brokers and three hedge funds. Then the traders went out and sold other CDS products that were not even related to actual loans on the books, but to imaginary indices of credit quality in the "widget" industry.

The credit risk of the system was hugely multiplied.

Instead of one $10 million credit risk loan, there are now ten $10 million credit risks on just one loan.

  • Three on solid banks - but will they stay solid?
  • One on a solid insurance company - probably OK.
  • Three on dodgy brokers - who knows?
  • And three on hedge funds - probably not OK in a real downturn.
Sign up for SMS so you never miss special events, exclusive offers, and weekly bonus trades.

The total credit risk in the system has been increased from the original $10 million loan to somewhere between $160 million to 200 million, depending on whether the banks and insurance company are financially solid.

Of course, a lot of those credit risks offset each other, so that if the company that took the loan goes bust, the only risk to the bank that sold all those CDS is to the profits it expected to make. But since it probably hedged those positions against others, if the company does go bust, and dodgy brokers and hedge funds stop paying up, the total losses in the system from that company's credit risk are likely to be a substantial multiple of the original $10 million loan.

But please don't think I was exaggerating when I said as many as 10 credit default swaps got sold for each loan.

The U.S. commercial loan market is worth about $5 trillion, yet the volume of CDS outstanding is currently no less than $50 trillion. In other words, a huge number of traders, salesmen and quants have been making money off this product, without any real "hedging" rationale at all.

And it all worked fine while the volume of defaults remained low, which is why the market expanded from $2 trillion to $50 trillion between 2000 and 2007.

A Ballooning Problem

There are two reasons reason why the CDS market has been able to expand so much beyond the size of the underlying debt markets:

  • Banking regulations and the lack of funding requirements for CDS: Banks are required by law to hold a certain amount of capital for loans they make - about 8 cents for every dollar in principle, but there are a number of loopholes that allow it to be less for certain types of loans. But there are very limited capital requirements for CDS, so banks and other CDS market participants can take on much more credit exposure through CDS than they could directly.
  • A loan must be funded: If you lend someone some money, you have to borrow it or use your own capital. However, if you take on the exact same risk through a CDS transaction, there is no need to put up any money, provided your counterparty will accept your credit risk.

For both these reasons, hedge funds have been large participants in the CDS market, because through credit default swaps the funds can take on much more risk (and receive much more in premiums) than their modest cash reserves would normally permit.

Big Defaults, Big Trouble

Suddenly home mortgages along with corporate credit and other types of consumer credit are in question and loss rates, which were very low in 2005-06, are soaring.

That spells big trouble for credit default swaps.

If just 10% of CDS underlying risks go bust, somewhere in the financial system there will be $5 trillion in losses.

Yes, there could well be $5 trillion of profits elsewhere in the system, because derivative transactions theoretically balance out. But once defaults start piling up, it's possible that many of those losses will become real, while the profits simply won't.

For example, hedge funds that have offered credit protection on risks far in excess of their current capital will quickly be unable to pay claims. Their counterparties will suffer unexpected losses, even though they thought they were protected by a CDS.

There are two sources of likely loss on CDS:

  • Default by the underlying borrowers, the companies that originally took out the loans.
  • And default by the banks or other financial firms that bought the credit default swap - counterparties in the endless chain of banks, insurance companies, hedge funds and general riff-raff that have done these deals.

Since the total outstanding balance of the CDS market is $50 trillion, compared with the entire U.S. home mortgage market at about $11 trillion and the subprime part of that market at only $1 trillion, you can see why people are worried. 

American International Group Inc. (AIG), the insurance company, lost $7 billion on its CDS portfolio in its fiscal quarter ended November 30, and that was on "super senior" CDS. The losses on this type of investment vehicle can get very big, very quickly. And since CDS are so new, they're completely untested in a real economic downturn.

The annual cost of credit default swaps based on the Markit CDS Investment Grade North America Index, which had bottomed out at 29 basis points (0.29%) in February 2007, soared to 220 basis points at the time of the Bear Stearns Cos. Inc. (BSC) bailout. The index was recently trading at 147.5 basis points, a significant improvement due to the U.S. Federal Reserve orchestrated rescue of Bear Stearns.

But Bear Stearns CDS were recently trading at 330 basis points, despite the guarantee of its obligations by the first-class credit of acquirer JPMorgan Chase & Co. (JPM), which means that investors are still wary.

If the CDS market itself thinks things are about to go wrong, they almost certainly are.

As Oliver Hardy used to say to Stan Laurel: "Another fine mess you got us into!"

News and Related Story Links:

  • Investopedia:
    Credit Default Swap
  • Money Morning:
    How Wall Street Bankers Helped Create the Current Credit Crisis
  • Money Morning:
    Bear Stearns Breakdown the Biggest Factor in Fed's Decision

Join the conversation. Click here to jump to comments…

35 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
trackback
The Real Reason for the Global Financial Crisis...the Story No One's Talking About
14 years ago

[…] isn’t the first time Money Morning has warned readers about the dangers of credit default swaps. And it won’t be the […]

0
StickClose
trackback
The Mighty Green Back » Blog Archive » The Story Behind AIG Collapse
14 years ago

[…] Money Morning Market Analysis:Credit Default Swaps: A $50 Trillion Problem. […]

0
StickClose
trackback
The Almighty Green Back » Blog Archive » The Inside Story of the Collapse of AIG
14 years ago

[…] Money Morning Market Analysis:Credit Default Swaps: A $50 Trillion Problem. […]

0
StickClose
trackback
The Credit Crisis and the Real Story Behind the Collapse of AIG
14 years ago

[…] Money Morning Market Analysis: Credit Default Swaps: A $50 Trillion Problem. […]

0
StickClose
trackback
How LIBOR Threatened to Destroy the Global Banking System | Jutia Group
14 years ago

[…] by the breakup of Yugoslavia and the Kosovo.  Hutchinson warned Money Morning readers about the dangers of credit-default swaps back in April – long before the collapse of American International Group Inc. (AIG) made the […]

0
StickClose
trackback
How LIBOR Threatened to Destroy the Global Banking System
14 years ago

[…] by the breakup of Yugoslavia and the Kosovo.  Hutchinson warned Money Morning readers about the dangers of credit-default swaps back in April – long before the collapse of American International Group Inc. (AIG) made the […]

0
StickClose
trackback
The U.S. Recession Will Be Painful – But it Could’ve Been Lots Worse
14 years ago

[…] swaps” a household word, Hutchinson penned a column warning Money Morning readers about the dangers of credit-default swaps, and his recent analysis of how the U.S. stock market would respond to the credit crisis proved to […]

0
StickClose
trackback
If Japan Bounces Back in the New Year, Investors Will, Too
14 years ago

[…] the breakup of Yugoslavia and the Kosovo War.  Hutchinson warned Money Morning readers about the dangers of credit-default swaps back in April – long before the collapse of American International Group Inc. (AIG) made them […]

0
StickClose
trackback
Credit default swaps: The Real Reason for the Global Financial Crisis...the Story No One's Talking About. | triggereventstrategist.com
14 years ago

[…] isn't the first time Money Morning has warned readers about the dangers of credit default swaps. And it won't be the […]

0
StickClose
trackback
Eastern Europe's Banks are Next in Line for a Bailout
14 years ago

[…] warned Money Morning readers about the dangers of credit-default swaps back in April – long before the collapse of American International Group Inc. (AIG) made those […]

0
StickClose
trackback
When it Comes to Naming Wall Street’s Worst Invention Ever, Credit Default Swaps Continue to Fill the Bill
14 years ago

[…] collapse of insurer American International Group Inc. But in an article featuring the headline, "Credit Default Swaps: A $50 Trillion Problem," Hutchinson warned Money Morning readers back in April 2008 that these derivative securities were […]

0
StickClose
trackback
Money Morning Expert Makes Noise with Market Call
14 years ago

[…] In April 2008, long before an implosion in a derivative security known as a "credit default swap" caused the implosion of AIG, Hutchinson warned Money Morning readers that credit default swaps were a $50 trillion problem. […]

0
StickClose
trackback
Why Dividends and Gold Are the Keys to Permanent Wealth
14 years ago

[…] Money Morning Special Report: Credit Default Swaps: A $50 Trillion Problem. […]

0
StickClose
trackback
Ban Credit Default Swaps? These Corporate Bankruptcies Show We Should
14 years ago

[…] the AbitibiBowater bankruptcy case, holders of credit default swaps played two key […]

0
StickClose
trackback
The Top 12 U.S. Banks: From Zombies to Hidden Gems
14 years ago

[…] warned Money Morning readers about the dangers of credit-default swaps back in April – long before the collapse of American International Group Inc. (AIG) made those […]

0
StickClose
trackback
Money Morning’s Hutchinson Makes the National News - Again
13 years ago

[…] In April 2008, long before an implosion in a derivative security known as a "credit default swap" caused the implosion of AIG, Hutchinson warned Money Morning readers that credit default swaps were a $50 trillion problem. […]

0
StickClose
trackback
How to Use High-Yielding Stocks to Pave the Way to Double-Digit Capital Gains
13 years ago

[…] Money Morning Contributing Editor Martin Hutchinson – a 27-year investing veteran of the global financial markets – has these days become well known for his timely market calls. Slate magazine early this year lauded Hutchinson's prescience for having correctly predicted the major correction of the U.S. stock market. In April 2008, long before an implosion in a derivative security known as a "credit default swap" caused the implosion of insurance giant American International Group Inc. (NYSE: AIG), Hutchinson warned Money Morning readers that credit default swaps were a $50 trillion problem. […]

0
StickClose
trackback
Will Global Warming Alarmism Disappear Like the Hula-Hoop?
13 years ago

[…] crisis, longtime market guru Martin Hutchinson has managed to do just that. Not only did he warn investors about the dangers of the credit default swap half a year before those deadly derivatives ignited the worldwide financial firestorm, he almost […]

0
StickClose
trackback
Could Goldman Sachs Share GM's Fate?
13 years ago

[…] the credit-default swap (CDS) been invented today, can anyone doubt that it would have been fenced in by restrictions so […]

0
StickClose
trackback
Hidden Traps Make Bank Stocks a Bad Deal
13 years ago

[…] incessantly reminded, the banks were all intimately inter-connected – not in the least by the diabolical credit-default-swap market. So a big failure could trigger a mass-market […]

0
StickClose
trackback
Why You Need to Look at these Three "Zombie-Free Zones"
13 years ago

[…] designated "Alpha-Bulldog" stocks into high-income/high-return portfolios for savvy investors. His warnings about the dangers of credit-default swaps – issued half a year before those deadly derivatives ignited the worldwide financial firestorm – […]

0
StickClose
trackback
Hedge Funds Take Direct Stakes in Commodities ... Should We Be Wary?
13 years ago

[…] his market calls before the meltdown that started last year were just as important. His warnings about the dangers of credit-default swaps – issued half a year before those deadly derivatives ignited the worldwide financial firestorm – […]

0
StickClose
trackback
Which of the "Rich Four" Countries Will Default First?
13 years ago

[…] Note: Martin Hutchinson has terrific foresight. He warned investors about the dangers of credit-default swaps – half a year before those deadly derivatives ignited the worldwide financial firestorm. Hutchinson […]

0
StickClose
trackback
Open Letter to Timothy Geithner: Is Your Nose Getting Longer?
13 years ago

[…] Money Morning Market Commentary: Credit Default Swaps: A $50 Trillion Problem. […]

0
StickClose
trackback
Five Ways to Ride the Commodities Bull
13 years ago

[…] his market calls before the meltdown that started last year were just as important. His warnings about the dangers of credit-default swaps – issued half a year before those deadly derivatives ignited the worldwide financial firestorm – […]

0
StickClose
trackback
Three Ways to Profit From Rising Oil Prices
13 years ago

[…] his market calls before the meltdown that started last year were just as important. His warnings about the dangers of credit-default swaps – issued half a year before those deadly derivatives ignited the worldwide financial firestorm – […]

0
StickClose
trackback
It's the World's Hottest Market - And it Isn't China
13 years ago

[…] his market calls before the meltdown that started last year were just as important. His warnings about the dangers of credit-default swaps – issued half a year before those deadly derivatives ignited the worldwide financial firestorm – […]

0
StickClose
trackback
Three Ways to Avoid Another Credit-Default-Swap Crisis
13 years ago

[…] been warning investors about the dangers of credit default swaps since very early in 2008, months before the problems surfaced. There […]

0
StickClose
trackback
Dodge a Possible Debt Debacle With These Two Stimulus-Plan Safety Plays
13 years ago

[…] – a financial crisis that, not surprisingly, Hutchinson is widely credited for having predicted and warned about well ahead of time. For those who aren't regular readers, and who might like an additional […]

0
StickClose
trackback
The Tobin Tax: The Fix-It Plan Wall Street Hates ... But Can't Seem to Kill
13 years ago

[…] and fights it every time it is proposed. The Tobin tax won't stop all their games – the margins on credit default swaps (CDS) are so high that a Tobin tax would affect them only modestly – but the benefits to markets […]

0
StickClose
trackback
The Shift Toward De-globalization is Bullish for Gold
13 years ago

[…] – a financial crisis that, not surprisingly, Hutchinson is widely credited for having predicted and warned about well ahead of time. For those who aren't regular readers, and who might like an additional […]

0
StickClose
trackback
Two Energy Stocks For a Post-Oil-Spill World
13 years ago

[…] – a financial crisis that, not surprisingly, Hutchinson is widely credited for having predicted and warned about well ahead of time. For those who aren't regular readers, and who might like an additional […]

0
StickClose
trackback
These Five Inflation Plays Will Provide Protection and Profits
12 years ago

[…] – a financial crisis that, not surprisingly, Hutchinson is widely credited for having predicted and warned about well ahead of time. With his "Alpha Bulldog" investing strategy – the crux of his Permanent […]

0
StickClose
trackback
Money Morning Mailbag: Taking a Closer Look at Dividend Stocks
12 years ago

[…] – a financial crisis that, not surprisingly, Hutchinson is widely credited for having predicted and warned about well ahead of time. For those who aren't regular readers, and who might like an additional […]

0
StickClose
trackback
What We Can Learn From The Stock Market Genius That Wall Street Loves to Ignore
12 years ago

[…] The crash came in 2008, just as Mandelbrot had forecast. The options-valuation models assessing credit-default swaps proved hopelessly wrong and the Value-at-Risk models assessing overall risk pushed several of their […]

0
StickClose


Latest News

June 7, 2023 • By Garrett Baldwin

(no title)

June 7, 2023 • By Garrett Baldwin

(no title)

June 7, 2023 • By Garrett Baldwin

A picture containing text, screenshot, font, line Description automatically generated
Postcards: This Value Strategy is Great for Finding Breakouts
Trending Stories
ABOUT MONEY MORNING

Money Morning gives you access to a team of market experts with more than 250 years of combined investing experience – for free. Our experts – who have appeared on FOXBusiness, CNBC, NPR, and BloombergTV – deliver daily investing tips and stock picks, provide analysis with actions to take, and answer your biggest market questions. Our goal is to help our millions of e-newsletter subscribers and Moneymorning.com visitors become smarter, more confident investors.

QUICK LINKS
About Us COVID-19 Announcements How Money Morning Works FAQs Contact Us Search Article Archive Forgot Username/Password Archives Profit Academy Research Your Team Videos Text Messaging Terms of Use
FREE NEWSLETTERS
Total Wealth Research Power Profit Trades Profit Takeover Penny Hawk Trading Today Midday Momentum Pump Up the Close
PREMIUM SERVICES
Money Map Press Home Money Map Report Fast Fortune Club Weekly Cash Clock Night Trader Microcurrency Trader Hyperdrive Portfolio Rocket Wealth Initiative Extreme Profit Hunters Profit Revolution Quantum Data Profits Live Trading Alliance Trade The Close Inside Money Trader Expiration Trader Flashpoint Trader Darknet Hyper Momentum Trader Alpha Accelerators Weekly Profit Cycles Brutus Alerts Resource Traders Alliance

© 2023 Money Morning All Rights Reserved. Protected by copyright of the United States and international treaties. Any reproduction, copying, or redistribution (electronic or otherwise, including the world wide web), of content from this webpage, in whole or in part, is strictly prohibited without the express written permission of Money Morning.

Address: 1125 N Charles St. | Baltimore, MD, 21201 | USA | Phone: 888.384.8339 | Disclaimer | Sitemap | Privacy Policy | Whitelist Us | Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information

wpDiscuz