Start the conversation
Comment on This Story
Or to contact Money Morning Customer Service, click here.
Four prominent Wall Street executives testified on Capitol Hill yesterday (Wednesday) about errors they committed during the financial crisis. But no amount of contrition or case making will be able to spare the financial services industry from the wrath of public opinion and a new tax to be imposed by President Barack Obama.
The bigwigs from Goldman Sachs Group Inc. (NYSE: GS), JP Morgan Chase & Co. (NYSE: JPM), Morgan Stanley (NYSE: MS), and Bank of America Corp. (NYSE: BAC) were called on yesterday (Wednesday) to explain themselves to the U.S. Congress' Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission (FCIC) – the ten-member commission appointed with goal of investigating the causes of the financial crisis.
"Over the course of this crisis, we as an industry caused a lot of damage," Brian Moynihan, chief executive of Bank of America, said before a standing-room only crowd in the House Ways and Means Committee room, The Wall Street Journal reported.
Morgan Stanley Chairman John Mack admitted "many firms were too highly leveraged, took on too much risk and did not have sufficient resources to manage those risks effectively in a rapidly changing environment."
However, the executives also defended their firms' actions. Goldman Sachs Chairman and CEO Lloyd Blankfein pointed to artificially low interest rates and the promotion of homeownership as "broad underlying factors" contributing to the financial crisis.
And BofA's Moynihan warned against limiting the size of banks and legislation to separate consumer and investment banking like the Glass-Steagall Act that was overturned in 1999.
"Those arguing for a return of Glass-Steagall are effectively arguing that Bear Stearns was a more stable entity than JPMorgan Chase," he said. "I don't see how that is tenable."
Still, no amount of posturing will be able to gird financial services against public outrage that is expected to come with the announcement of fourth-quarter and full year earnings, which are expected to yield record breaking profits and millions of dollars in year-end bonuses.
"People are angry. They have a right to be. Acts of God will happen. These were acts of men," said Phil Angelides, Chairman of the Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission.
It's that anger that President Barack Obama is using as justification for a new tax on financial institutions, which is meant to offset taxpayer losses stemming from the Troubled Asset Relief Program (TARP) and help reduce the deficit. The president is scheduled to announce the new tax today (Friday), with the full details appearing in the fiscal 2011 budget that will be submitted to Congress next month.
What banks will be charged, how much those banks will have to pay, and when will they be required to pay are all questions that have so far been left unanswered. But early reports indicate that 20 of the largest U.S. banks will be affected.
One option under consideration involves placing a fee on a bank's liabilities, a number that theoretically represents the amount of risk a bank takes on.
The only thing that's certain that Obama & Co. won't have a hard time selling the new tax to the American public.
"The politics on this is really quite easy," Doug Elliott, a fellow at the Brookings Institution in Washington and a former managing director at JPMorgan Chase & Co. told Bloomberg. "The public would be supportive of anything up to shooting and burning the bankers."
Analysts say earnings at financial companies rose 120% in the fourth quarter, accounting for all of the income increase in the Standard & Poor's 500 Index, according to a report by Bloomberg News. According to the report, analysts are more bullish on financials than any other sector, with earnings expected to triple by 2011 to $19.51.
News & Related Story Links:
- Wall Street Journal:
Wall Street Executives Admit Missteps at Hearing - Bloomberg:
Blankfein Defends Goldman Sachs Amid Grilling by Crisis Panel
- Bloomberg:
Obama Bank-Fee Plan May Tap Voter Anger Over Bailouts, Bonuses - Money Morning:
Why You Should Mark January 13 on Your Calendar - Money Morning:
Obama Bank Tax No Reason to Flee Financials - Money Morning:
Shareholders – Not Obama – Should Be Curbing Wall Street Bonuses
Has anyone considered how incompetent the risk officers and fund managers were in banks in '07 before the crisis? Did they know their jobs ?? Shouldn't they be fired ?
Their fund managers follow theoretical philosophies of mandates, deliberately causing losses to clients with the excuse to rebalance portfolios, following formulas that clearly could not even hint of a problem …. yet they walk away with lavish salaries and bonuses while people on the street suffer ?
Do we not expect results when we pay for products, or services from a handy man or a restaurant? How can a bunch of trained MBA's get away with blaming their lack of performances on their own theoretical formulas they push on the public?
If this is not the biggest con game being run, then what is ?
'Shooting and burning', as the author writes, may be too kind a treatment !
I believe the Federal government should break the four major banks apart they are to large if the CEO's want to play hardball.
If I were the President I would show them all who was the boss in this country!
These CEO's think they are the untouchables in the Untied States of America!
The people in the United States could close out all there accounts from the four major Banks
Find a smaller bank that would treat you better…
Boycott the Banks I beat we would hear a different tune coming for these CEO fat cat to big to fail.
I cant for the life of wonder why the shareholder and board members have not ask for the resignation of three of these CEO'S over the financial scandal these major Banks are facing!
This tax on banks may have popular support, but it will damage the economy even more than it has already been hurt. This tax on banks will be passed on to the consumer. One has to ask if this destruction of the economy is not planned and for what purpose
Bonuses should be a percentage of salary not ever larger than salary.They also should be only for great performance,never expected or in a contract.I feel the people who make up these employment contracts with bonuses included should be fired also.I also feel that we have to put an import duty on everything that anybody is bringing into this country,even our own companies based here ,greed has taken over .I learned in college that the American Government would have to become a totalitarian type of government (not socialist )and sit on or slap industries hands when they tried to sell us down the river,like they did out of greed.Put on the inport duty ,take that money to subsidize bussiness here to produce competing products and get us all back to work NOW !!!!!!!! also subsidize them to sell cheaper over seas like they did to us,we got sold down the river by Ceo's and Politicians looking the other way.We have to fight fire with fire or burn like we are now,lets get with it and the hell with worldwide ,charity begins at home.Lets stop selling America off one piece at a time.Only citizens should be able to buy.Treasury bills and bond in one thousand and five hundred dollar amounts so we americans can buy back our own depts to hell with foriegners.Middle America is fed up big time.I have never written anything or anyone before but its time.We need at least one more or 2 political parties .Start running the country according to the original constitution not just for the rich.Get rid of the lobyists,God kicked the carpetbaggers out of the temple,write all agreements and laws in plain english so everybody can understand it and see the hidden agendas .Its time to start producing everything here,go for off shore oil etc,Don't wait for other countries to go off our shores and drill.Our forefathers came here to be free and we have been selling it off a piece at a time ,this has to be stopped now and go back to the way it was.WAKE UP THIS IS A FIGHT FOR OUR VERY EXISTANCE .Bring back the death penalty and the firing squad for treason,its survival of the good people get rid of the bad apples,they will spoil the butch.I could go on but this will probably be deleted anyway.God Bless America ,I have a feelings we are going to need it ??????
Hey Walter,
Your forefathers came here, found a free peoples already here and ripped them off, raped and pilaged them and wrapped them up into reservations on crap land. Tit for tat. Take your sanctimonious patriotism and go back to where your ancestors came from!
This tax no doubt will be passed on to the consumer. Every regulation placed on the banks will help the big banks and hurt the small banks. Is there tax that Obama does not like?
put in in the people hands what we got tio lose