Share This Article

Facebook LinkedIn
Twitter Reddit
Print Email
Pinterest Gmail
Yahoo
Money Morning
×
  • Invest
    • Best Stocks to Buy
    • Stock Forecasts
    • Stocks to Sell Now
    • Stock Market Predictions
    • Technology Stocks
    • Best REITs to Buy Now
    • IPO Stocks
    • Penny Stocks
    • Dividend Stocks
    • Cryptocurrencies
    • Cannabis Investing
    • Angel Investing
  • Trade
    • How to Trade Options
    • Best Trades to Make Now
    • Options Trading Strategies
    • Weekly Trade Recommendations
  • Retire
    • Income Investing Guide
    • Retirement Articles
  • More
    • Money Morning LIVE
    • Special Investing Reports
    • Our ELetters
    • Our Premium Services
    • Videos
    • Meet Our Experts
    • Profit Academy
Login My Member Benefits Archives Research Your Team About Us FAQ
  • Invest
    • Best Stocks to Buy
    • Stock Forecasts
    • Stocks to Sell Now
    • Stock Market Predictions
    • Technology Stocks
    • Best REITs to Buy Now
    • IPO Stocks
    • Penny Stocks
    • Dividend Stocks
    • Cryptocurrencies
    • Cannabis Investing
    • Angel Investing
    ×
  • Trade
    • How to Trade Options
    • Best Trades to Make Now
    • Options Trading Strategies
    • Weekly Trade Recommendations
    ×
  • Retire
    • Income Investing Guide
    • Retirement Articles
    ×
  • More
    • Money Morning LIVE
    • Special Investing Reports
    • Our ELetters
    • Our Premium Services
    • Videos
    • Meet Our Experts
    • Profit Academy
    ×
  • Subscribe
Enter stock ticker or keyword
×
5 Ways to Beat the Fed (and Crush Inflation)

Email this Article

Send with mail | ahoo instead.
Required Needs to be a valid email
Required Needs to be a valid email
Healthcare Reform Losers: Companies Providing Retiree Benefits Face Multi-Million Dollar Tax Costs
http://mney.co/1GFGUWo
Required Please enter the correct value.
Twitter

Healthcare Reform Losers: Companies Providing Retiree Benefits Face Multi-Million Dollar Tax Costs

By Kerri Shannon, Associate Editor, Money Morning • March 26, 2010

View Comments

Start the conversation

Comment on This Story Click here to cancel reply.

Or to contact Money Morning Customer Service, click here.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Some HTML is OK

After sending letters of protest to Congress in the months prior to the healthcare law's approval, U.S. companies are now facing multi-million dollar after-tax hits this year due to a tax provision in the new legislation, labeling them healthcare reform losers instead of winners.

Part of the new healthcare law places a federal income tax on government subsidies given to companies that provide retirees and their spouses with drug benefit plans. The 28% subsidy was created as Medicare Part D, adding a prescription plan for senior citizens to the Medicare Act of 2003. To encourage companies to continue offering retirees a drug plan, the tax-free subsidy reduced companies' costs. Fewer senior citizens then went through Medicare's prescription program - which would have cost taxpayers much more than the subsidy price.

Caterpillar Inc (NYSE: CAT) and Deere & Company (NSYE: DE) are just two of the businesses that fought the new stipulations. The manufacturers estimate the tax will cost them $100 million and $150 million this year, respectively. Other companies who will pay handsomely include AK Steel Corp. (NYSE: AKS) with $31 million in charges, and Honeywell International Inc. (NYSE: HON) with an estimated fee of $42 million.

Consulting firm Towers Watson & Co. (NYSE: TW) estimates these taxes could cost companies about $233 per person receiving drug benefits - a hefty price tag when a company gives benefits to 40,000 retirees, like Caterpillar.

Overall, more than 3,500 companies offer drug benefits to 6.3 million retirees. Although the tax won't be effective until 2011, accounting practices force companies to recognize the fees in the period in which the law is signed. That means the tax could nab $14 billion from corporate profits in a year when companies were hoping to recover from huge losses during the recession.

"From our point of view, a tax increase like this cannot come at a worse time," Jim Dugan, Caterpillar spokesman, told The Wall Street Journal. Caterpillar's income fell 75% in 2009, and worldwide machinery sales were down 20% in the three-month period ending Feb. 28 compared to the same period last year.

Caterpillar addressed the issues last week in a letter to Congressional leaders, stating the costs will disadvantage them against global competitors who are not facing increased healthcare expenses. Industrial and manufacturing companies, like Caterpillar and Deere, will take the worst hit as their businesses are still rebuilding from slacking periods of construction activity.

"This could be a huge hit for bigger companies," Roland McDevitt, healthcare director for Towers Watson, told Bloomberg. "This will be the kind of charge that will get the CFO looking and asking what are we doing here?"

Ten chief financial officers (CFOs) foresaw the healthcare reform's consequences and sent a letter to Congress asking them to reconsider the tax treatment. In the Dec. 11 plea, companies including Caterpillar, Deere, and The Boeing Co. (NYSE: BA) claimed the changes would "negatively impact both retirees and companies."

The CFOs contested the "double-dipping" accusation that they receive a tax-deduction for the cost of coverage in addition to the 28% subsidy, saying companies are still absorbing more costs than the government or the retirees. Adding to those expenses could encourage companies to drop the coverage, leaving retirees to shift to Medicare and costing the government more than estimated.

"If more companies than predicted by the Government Accountability Office shift away from coverage, then the provision could result in a net revenue loss rather than the predicted slight revenue gain," the CFOs wrote. "The impact of the proposed Medicare Part D changes would be felt throughout the overall U.S. economy as corporate entities and investors would be forced to react."

The tax is projected to generate $4.5 billion in revenue, but that number would drastically fall if enough companies decided to drop the benefits to avoid the subsidy tax. That would push retirees on to government-funded Medicare prescription plans.

Despite the White House's claims that the changes should not affect retirees, companies are claiming otherwise. After the healthcare bill was signed into law Verizon Communications Inc. (NYSE: VZ) sent a note to employees saying the tax would make the subsidy less valuable and could have implications for retirees and employers.

Another letter sent last week to President Barack Obama and Congress from 130 economists examined how the new taxes and fees would affect employers. They looked at more than just the retiree drug subsidy tax and drew similarly negative conclusions about the effect on companies.

"While Speaker Pelosi asserts that health care reform will create four million jobs, we disagree," that letter read. "In our view, the health care bill contains a number of provisions that will eliminate jobs, reduce hours and wages, and limit future job creation."

News and Related Story Links:

  • The Wall Street Journal:
    Caterpillar Takes Hit on Health Care
  • Bloomberg:
    Obama Tax's $14 Billion Charge Starts at Caterpillar
  • Money Morning:
    Drug Companies and Hospitals Get a Boost from Healthcare Reform
  • Money Morning:
    The Year of the Tiger is the Perfect Time for Caterpillar Inc.
  • Money Morning:
    Freakish Winter Freezes Some Profit Plays, Heats Up Some Others
  • Newsvine.com:
    130 Economists Sign Warning Letter To Obama And Congress

Join the conversation. Click here to jump to comments…

Login
guest
guest
3 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Fivi
Fivi
12 years ago

I am not sure why ended up with these dummies in Congress when this country has so many smart business minds. This wonderful America will become much worse than Europe if we keep these progressive socialists in the office. I live under socialize medicine and it's bad. Americans will wake up but it will be too late.

I hope these large companies and wall street will stop funding these so called progressive campaigns.

0
Reply
Nick
Nick
12 years ago

Once again we see a poorly thoughtout plan become a law. This administration again shows it's disinterest in the very companies that are necessary to create jobs. By forcing this healthcare reform bill through Congress versus getting bipartisian support this President has again alienated the very business groups that are so important to any long lasting recovery. Hats off to the CEO's who have responded to the hidden provisions in this law and are taking the necessary steps to protect their companies. As these companies cost go up either profits go down and thus fewer jobs and benefits or cost passed onto the consumer. (When is the last time you saw a gas station eat a rise in oil) The Administration is outmaneuvered again, but that's pretty easy when your up against politicians who have never had to work for a living or meet a payroll!

0
Reply
David Billings
David Billings
12 years ago

It is totally outrageous that Congress has seen fit not only to subsidize our largest companies with our money, but to give them a tax write off for that same money!

Where are the so-called "free market" pundits on this issue?

0
Reply
LIVE
Visit Money Morning Live


Latest News

January 19, 2023 • By Money Morning Stock Research Team

These Stocks Could Go To $0

January 9, 2023 • By Money Morning Stock Research Team

The Government Is Pouring $391 Billion Into These Stocks - Buy Now

December 27, 2022 • By Money Morning Staff Reports

6 IPOs in 2023 You Can’t Afford to Miss
Trending Stories
ABOUT MONEY MORNING

Money Morning gives you access to a team of market experts with more than 250 years of combined investing experience – for free. Our experts – who have appeared on FOXBusiness, CNBC, NPR, and BloombergTV – deliver daily investing tips and stock picks, provide analysis with actions to take, and answer your biggest market questions. Our goal is to help our millions of e-newsletter subscribers and Moneymorning.com visitors become smarter, more confident investors.

QUICK LINKS
About Us COVID-19 Announcements How Money Morning Works FAQs Contact Us Search Article Archive Forgot Username/Password Archives Profit Academy Research Your Team Videos Text Messaging Terms of Use
FREE NEWSLETTERS
Total Wealth Research Power Profit Trades Profit Takeover This Is VWAP Penny Hawk Trading Today Midday Momentum Pump Up the Close
PREMIUM SERVICES
Money Map Press Home Money Map Report Fast Fortune Club Weekly Cash Clock Night Trader Microcurrency Trader Hyperdrive Portfolio Rocket Wealth Initiative Extreme Profit Hunters Profit Revolution Warlock's World Penny Nation Quantum Data Profits Live Trading Alliance Trade The Close Inside Money Trader Expiration Trader Vega Burst Trader Flashpoint Trader Darknet Hyper Momentum Trader

© 2023 Money Morning All Rights Reserved. Protected by copyright of the United States and international treaties. Any reproduction, copying, or redistribution (electronic or otherwise, including the world wide web), of content from this webpage, in whole or in part, is strictly prohibited without the express written permission of Money Morning.

Address: 1125 N Charles St. | Baltimore, MD, 21201 | USA | Phone: 888.384.8339 | Disclaimer | Sitemap | Privacy Policy | Whitelist Us | Do Not Sell My Info

wpDiscuz