Start the conversation
Comment on This Story
Or to contact Money Morning Customer Service, click here.
SHANGHAI, The People's Republic of China - Given what you may have heard about Chinese property values in recent months, it may surprise you to learn that Chinese real estate investors are extremely value oriented.
And so are the institutional investors I've run into during my latest investment-research visit to this country. These institutional players want to lock up some valuable land parcels before 2020. That's the date by which 500 million Chinese citizens are expected to have moved into China's cities as part of the greatest urban migration ever recorded.
You can do the math: We're talking about a group that's 1.6 times the entire U.S. population ... moving from China's countryside to its cities in the next 10 years.
The Mass Migration "Big Bang"
A population shift of this magnitude can't help but be a major catalyst for increasing real estate values - especially in such top-tier cities as Beijing and Shanghai, where I am as I write this. This massive urbanization will also significantly shift the market dynamics of second-tier municipalities - such as Chongqing, where literally millions of people are pouring in from the countryside.
Some pundits, such as noted short-seller Jim Chanos, say this is already happening. Back in January, citing the vacancies that pepper the cities I've just named and the flood of speculative capital he says has washed through them, Chanos quipped that China is "Dubai times 1,000," - a sound-bite that's kept him in the media spotlight ever since.
Personally, I find that more than a little ironic considering he's never even set foot in China and didn't even begin studying China until last summer, critics say.
To hear Chanos and others talk about their concerns about a Chinese economic bubble, you'd think Chinese real estate developers and investors are essentially playing with M onopoly money.
My experience suggests otherwise. So does some of the latest market data that I've reviewed. One study, for instance, suggests that Chinese real estate has underperformed the benchmark MSCI China Index by nearly 30%.
The point is that Chinese real estate, on the whole, appears to be significantly undervalued - even at this stage of the game - when compared to regional alternatives in Hong Kong and Singapore, two other Asian markets that are a lot further along on the economic-development curve.
The bottom line - and the point that I keep coming back to - is this: If China's real-estate market is as far out of whack as some people suggest based on vacancies, property-related prices should be falling - even cratering.
But they're not.
In fact, they're rising - and so is overall growth.
China: The White Hot Economy
Just yesterday (Thursday), in fact, China announced first-quarter gross-domestic-product (GDP) growth of 11.9%, the country's fastest expansion in nearly three years and a rate that was faster than what analysts were expecting.
China's economy had advanced at a 10.9% pace in the final quarter of last year.
Stephen Green, head of Greater China research for Standard Chartered PLC (PINK: SCBFF) here in Shanghai, told MarketWatch.com that central planners in Beijing could be faced with an asset-price bubble in the second half of the year that could trigger a sharp credit contraction in 2011 - unless they're able to throttle growth back to a more sustainable pace.
"There are signs of overheating," Green said in the interview.
Beijing is well aware of the stakes and is taking steps to manage China's growth - with some signs of success.
As part of yesterday's report on economic growth, Beijing said that March's consumer price index (CPI) for China was 2.4% higher than a year earlier. That was down from the 2.7% increase in February, and is below the 2.6% increase that surveys by both Dow Jones Newswires and Reuters showed analysts were expecting.
In the real-estate realm, Beijing is raising reserve requirements for lenders, is tightening up on permits and construction licenses, and is even taking steps to halt illegal development. In some parts of China, local developers will often construct entire buildings and never pull a permit.
As incomes increase and China's consumer class continues to emerge, such pastimes as golf become all the rage. One result: Even though golf courses aren't exactly easy to hide, there may be hundreds of illegal links operating throughout China right now, the China Daily reported in a story that I read during my visit here.
If the markets were as overbuilt as some pundits allege, there wouldn't be any competition for the best properties. Instead, that competition is as fierce as I've ever seen it - an observation that was seconded by many of the private-equity investors I talked with at the Halter Financial Summit that I attended in Shanghai. Like me, these folks have been actively investing in the Asian markets for decades.
There's a very clear trend developing. As the property prices in Beijing and Shanghai increase in expense, many companies, investors and developers are shifting their focus to the second- and third-tier cities that have yet to experience the urbanization rush of their much-larger first-tier counterparts. That's going to broaden the overall advance, creating a more-sustainable environment for real estate investing and development even if major pockets of urban overvaluation exist today. It's precisely the pattern we described and told Money Morning readers to expect several years ago.
The speculative excesses that do exist appear to be limited to very-high-end residential real estate (read that to mean ultra-luxury real estate) in the primary cities. Over -speculation hasn't meaningfully impacted the commercial-real-estate sector, or the more-mainstream housing sectors, although that could still happen . Residential projects aimed at the emerging consumer class, as well as the business-related real estate projects that are so important to a nation's economic advance, both remain in the realm of "investments" - and not speculation - which is why they continue to have very clear government support as part of central planning objectives and China's ongoing growth.
In other words, Beijing is willing to let the "Ferrari set" flame out, but clearly wants the middle class to succeed because that group's emergence will create a foundation for both social and economic stability.
No wonder the enlightened institutional investors that I've talked with here in China continue to be optimistic. They understand that they could sit on the sidelines and wait for the corrections that periodically come along. But these investors also know that the "bottom" of the next correction could easily be represented by much higher than the prices we're seeing today - and probably will be.
How to Profit From China's Mass Migration
What does this mean for you?
If you're actually "on the ground" here, and have enough money and the ability to do your own due diligence - or "DD" as the Chinese call it - you can begin hunting in the second- and third-tier cities, right alongside everybody else headed that direction. There's certainly money to be made there in private equity.
For U.S.-based investors, however, there's a much-easier way to participate. Consider investing in one of a handful of exchange-traded funds (ETFs) that offer exposure to China's real-estate market - such as the Claymore/Alpha Shares China Real Estate ETF (NYSE: TAO) and the Claymore Alpha Shares China All-Cap Fund (NYSE: YAO). The first fund concentrates specifically on real estate, while the second fund is more broadly diversified and includes banking, construction companies and developers.
A more generalized alternative is the iShares FTSE NAREIT Asia ETF (NYSE: IFAS), which is a regional play that has approximately 8% to 10% of its holdings allocated to Chinese real estate. There are also several closed-end funds that offer a similar, generalized exposure, including the RMR Asia Pacific Real Estate Fund (AMEX: RAP).
As you incorporate this sector into your overall investment strategy, it's important to keep in mind the general advice that I use as part of my own portfolio strategy for China. The Asian giant remains the biggest wealth-creation opportunity of our lifetime - in the long run. In the near term, you be certain there will be volatility, periodic pullbacks and even corrections.
And while the real-estate sector offers some of the best long-term appreciation of any China-oriented investment category, the investments I've just mentioned are all trading near to the tops of their 52-week ranges. And that means they could be poised for a short-term pull back just as easily as a long-term breakout. Position any investments accordingly.
[Editor's Note: Money Morning's Keith Fitz-Gerald is still perfect.
With his latest trade, Fitz-Gerald is a perfect 23 for 23 with his Geiger Index advisory service. A veteran trader, skilled analyst and noted market tactician, Fitz-Gerald is able to see through the confusing haze of today's quickly changing markets, which enables him to visualize and understand what the future holds. This ability to see into the future -predicting looming changes while also divining the profit opportunities those changes will create - is one of Fitz-Gerald's greatest strengths.
That's a big reason that Fitz-Gerald - Money Morning's chief investment strategist and the editor of the New China Trader advisory service - has maintained a perfect record with the Geiger Index.
If you would like more information about the Geiger Index, please click here.]
News and Related Story Links:
- Money Morning View From China Report (2010):
Washington - Not China - Is the Real Manipulator Here. - About.com:
What is the Current U.S. Population? - Wikipedia:
Chongqing. - Wikipedia:
Private Equity. - China Daily:
Illegal golf course threatens conservation area. - The New York Times:
Contrarian Investor Sees Economic Crash in China. - MarketWatch.com:
China's quarterly GDP expands more-than-expected 11.9%. - Halter Financial Summit (2010):
Official Web Site. - Money Morning News Analysis:
The China Connection: Why Dubai is Really Interested In MGM, - Investopedia:
Due Diligence. - InvestorWords.com:
Closed-End Fund.
About the Author
Keith is a seasoned market analyst and professional trader with more than 37 years of global experience. He is one of very few experts to correctly see both the dot.bomb crisis and the ongoing financial crisis coming ahead of time - and one of even fewer to help millions of investors around the world successfully navigate them both. Forbes hailed him as a "Market Visionary." He is a regular on FOX Business News and Yahoo! Finance, and his observations have been featured in Bloomberg, The Wall Street Journal, WIRED, and MarketWatch. Keith previously led The Money Map Report, Money Map's flagship newsletter, as Chief Investment Strategist, from 20007 to 2020. Keith holds a BS in management and finance from Skidmore College and an MS in international finance (with a focus on Japanese business science) from Chaminade University. He regularly travels the world in search of investment opportunities others don't yet see or understand.
A fascinating article – once again! However, I am slightly concerned regarding the latest figures coming out of the country. It has been suggested many times that a certain degree of "massaging" takes place between the grass-roots and the upper echelons of central government. I cannot help but feel that, to a degree, this massaging takes place with the full knowledge of the centre as it helps to focus "western" thought in (their perceived) right direction. Maybe I'm wrong, but often it is a value to be slightly contrarian in outlook.
WHAT WILL THE CHINESE EAT?! WHAT WILL HAPPEN TO THEIR COUNTRYSIDE?
They eat same like you, might be better than you. I think.
IRON RICEBOWL TO IRON SKYSCRAPER
Obviously China is undergoing big changes, and challenges. The governing class, many Western Educated, are trying to manage a New China. In contrast, democracies around the world are falling into further disrepair with each financial policy which further devalues their fiat paper currencies. The future seems to belong to the country(s) who are the best at managing the circumstances they find themselves in.
As far as innovation in China goes, I think we still have the lead. The Chinese did not even invent the famous "fortune cookie". I seriously doubt they have invented anything of economic consequence since the days of Marco Polo. China is great at copying and assembling someone else's designs as part of the global supply chain. They buy as built automotive brands right off the shelf, but what new designs have they come up with on their own? None that I can recall. So, a growing China really appears to be a more tightly managed China, from the Central Planners in Bejing.
IRON RICEBOWL TO IRON SKYSCRAPER
Obviously China is undergoing big changes, and challenges. The governing class, many Western Educated, are trying to manage a New China. In contrast, democracies around the world are falling into further disrepair with each financial policy which further devalues their fiat paper currencies. The future seems to belong to the country(s) who are the best at managing the circumstances they find themselves in.
nowadays chinese people can eat everything as they like,but something triditional they may also cherish.for eample,the southerner usually have rice as the main course ,however the northerner usually have wheaten food.for the breakfast, a lot of old people get used to eat porridge ,but younger people just eat bread milk or not eat anything.i am now living in big city like shanghai ,the job oppotunities here is really a lot and payment higher.Accoringly is the more pollution and higher pressure.contract to city life ,the countreside is less pressure and more leisurely.i may choose work for ten to twenty years in big cities and spend my left time in countryside.
What percent exposure to China is prudent with a $100,000 portfolio? And why are China stocks so volatile? After careful "DD" with much research I still get my head handed to me with individual stocks. I've tried CGA (your rec), CAAS, CAGC, EJ, even YAO a while back all with the same bloody result. Is it better to go with a managed mutual fund? Tripled my investment on Oberweis China Op Fund couple years ago.
Yea, I also think China real estate is not a bubble per se. Many factors leading to this rise in prices. Here is a video of a Californian who runs a realty company in China. It seems the people not in China think it's a bubble but not the ones inside
Jim Chanos has made many billions identifying over-priced entities. No, he never set foot in China, but he also never set foot in Enron's or Tyco's corporate headquarters yet made a lot of money from their demise. This author makes his money by giving financial advice (often incorrectly, as pointed out) but Jim Chanos made his billions by taking short positions in overvalued situations and has rarely been wrong. Who would you choose to invest your money?
Hong Kong will be he first to fall.
[…] economies – especially China and India -grow, there is a strong trend toward urbanization. People are leaving the countryside for the cities in droves in order to reap the promise of the glob…. This secular process alone places huge demands on the existing infrastructure. This […]