Few are willing to acknowledge the threat of stagflation, but reports showing inflation rising more quickly than expected – even as growth is slowing – indicate that this scourge of the 1970s may be stalking the U.S. economy.
Every economic report nudges the United States closer to the definition of stagflation – a condition marked by slow economic growth, high unemployment, and soaring prices.
Although many economists believe the sluggish economy will moderate inflation, that's not what happened in the 1970s.
"The belief that you can't have inflation and high unemployment is nonsense; we had 25% inflation in the U.K. in 1975, in the middle of a recession," said Money Morning Global Investment Strategist Martin Hutchinson.
Hutchinson has repeatedly warned Money Morning readers that the U.S. Federal Reserve's easy money policies would lead to inflation without fostering economic growth.
In the past couple of months, Hutchinson's fears have been realized.
The Stark Reality
The July consumer price index (CPI), released yesterday (Thursday) by the U.S. Labor Department, increased 0.5% from June – more than double the 0.2% economists had expected.
The Labor Department's producer price index (PPI) report for July, which tracks what businesses pay for goods, rose 0.2% – also twice what economists had expected.
Economic growth, meanwhile, has been sluggish at best. The economy expanded by just 1.3% in the second quarter, following 0.4% growth in the first quarter. A healthy economy should have a gross domestic product (GDP) growth of 3% or higher.
Yesterday's weekly jobless claims report also inched higher, to 408,000, which suggests little progress is being made on reducing the 9.1% unemployment rate. What's more, the report showed hourly wages falling 0.1% in July and 1.3% from a year earlier, making it difficult even for those who have jobs to cope with the rising prices.
In yet another report yesterday, the Philadelphia Federal Reserve Bank said factory activity in the mid-Atlantic region fell from +2 in July to -30.7 in August – its lowest level since March 2009. Readings below zero indicate shrinking manufacturing activity.
If the Fed and government lawmakers continue to ignore the threat of stagflation – Fed Chairman Ben S. Bernanke has repeatedly downplayed inflation concerns – the stage will be set for a long and painful climb out of a deep economic morass.
"When this happened before — back in the 1972-73 time frame — it took a full decade of punishingly high interest rates and the commitment of a Fed chairman named Paul A. Volcker to solve," Hutchinson said.
Numbers Games
Chairman Bernanke tends to brush aside the usually higher overall CPI number in favor of the so-called "core" inflation number that excludes food and fuel costs. In July core inflation rose just 0.2%, far less than the 0.5% jump in the overall CPI.
Food and fuel, along with clothing, have been among the categories showing the highest increases. The government excludes them because it says their volatile price swings skew its data, but average Americans can't exclude those daily necessities from their budgets.
"The CPI is a joke," Money Morning Chief Investment Strategist Keith Fitz-Gerald said earlier this year. "Every American knows that in reality it's far higher than that based on what they feel in their wallets every day."
Furthermore, the numbers are more often reported as changes from the previous month as opposed to the previous year, which softens their impact. The CPI has risen 3.6% in the past 12 months, for example.
In fact, the annual numbers in several individual categories show why so many middle-class Americans are struggling to make ends meet. The price of gasoline, for example was up 33.6% over last July and fuel oil up 37.2%. The "food at home" category, which is mostly groceries, was up 5.4%, with dairy products up 7.9%.
The PPI is up 7.2% from last July, which means businesses have eaten some price increases rather than pass them on to customers. Going forward, businesses either will have to raise prices further – adding to consumer inflation – or will have to accept lower profits. Both options would be bad for the economy.
Fed Failure
The Fed – which is charged with keeping inflation in check – has not taken such numbers into consideration as it has held interest rates near zero and embarked on "quantitative easing" policies that have flooded the markets with money.
In effect, the Fed is pouring gasoline on a fire that it should be extinguishing.
"Ultra-low interest rates and excess money supply growth are what's been driving inflation," Hutchinson said. "They raise commodity prices, which over time feeds into inflation in general."
The threat of stagflation paints a dark picture of the fate of the U.S. economy in the months and even years ahead.
It's a grim landscape of high unemployment and companies treading water while the Fed declines to reverse course. In such a scenario, Hutchison believes inflation could go beyond 1970s levels.
"Once inflation takes off, there's nothing holding it to the 10% level it peaked at in the late 1970s," Hutchinson said. "Bernanke's "no interest rate hike till 2013' will look very silly as inflation zooms higher."
News and Related Story Links:
- Money Morning:
Two Easy Ways to Save Your Wealth From 1970s-Style Stagflation - Money Morning:
"Stealth QE3" Comes to Fruition – Soaring Inflation is Next - Money Morning:
Helicopter Ben is at It Again: Four Ways to Protect Yourself From the Fed's Next Flyover - Money Morning:
Sorry Mr. Bernanke: ThereWillbe a Double-Dip Recession - MarketWatch:
Producer prices climb hotter-than-forecast 0.2% - Bloomberg News:
U.S. Consumer Prices Rise More Than Forecast - Reuters:
Regional factory activity hits 2-1/2 year low - Associated Press:
Consumer prices rose by the most since March - Wikipedia:
Stagflation - Bureau of Labor Statistics:
Consumer Price Index
Good article and exactly correct.
Of interest to the US consumer is the devaluation of its currency this in part is controlled by sales of goods in Europe. But the controlling factor is the IMF and its only interested in profiteering at the expense of the weaker countries like Portugal and Greece. Its not controlling the economy of the eurozone countries, market conditions are, and no one wants overpriced inferior products, that every sector of eurozone manufacturers produce in not needed multitude, in an overvalued Euro currency.
The next stage of this manufactured block is liquidation of the weakest, followed by more currency printing, the currency increasing, ending with depression and devaluation. The risk cannot be averted because others have crossed that bridge and were first to revalue their currency.
What happens now is that eurozone countries have price hikes on everything, effectively making the entire Euro currency countries uncompetitive to its export markets and its own consumers who import lower priced better quality products.
These price increases will determine the pressure on the Euro and the consumer who has less to spend and the spiral is downhill for both. It was and is way overvalue as stated in October 2010, and now all other currencies are in the race to devalue at the expense of the irrevocably fixed Euro. The result a double dip recession and inflation out of control.
We have Democracy when EU leaders allow it.
This explains why the EU experiment, and the Euro has failed, (we are being lead by Dictators)
The EU is a dictatorship, where the German and French leaders do not allow democracy. The threat made to Greece’s Prime minister, when he was told quite clearly Greece would receive no further Money. If a Greek “referendum” was held is outrageous, this is gun to the head diplomacy not democracy, Greece and its people have the right to a referendum. Just like the public majority in Britain who wanted a referendum on the Lisbon Treaty, before the prime minister forced it through.
Governments are printing money to create hyper inflation, deliberately” to lower its debts. The revaluation of the British pound and US Dollar is a devaluation of your money. What this means is “your bank savings and pension will be worth peanuts. (£1000, will be worth (£250) or less by 2013.
The EU will just print more Euros; these are irrevocably fixed, “with a fraudulent value against other currencies. This has the effect of exchanging £pounds for peanuts, whenever you trade with Euro member states. And the paymaster general Germany, who lost the war, will win the battle and thrive on your £pound or §Dollar, while you shell the peanuts.
Britain is being fed a daily dose of hype about the EU being an important export market, but is it, Britain is the Europeans Unions most important customer, each BMW and Renault sold in Britain means less cars made in Britain and lots of peanuts to choke on while Britain is being filled with Frances illegal immigrants.
The Euro is massively overvalued and everyone knows it, the next bailout protest will force governments to act.