Subscribe to Money Morning get daily headlines subscribe now! Money Morning Private Briefing today's private briefing Access Your Profit Alerts

AIG and the New Victim Mentality

I'm hurt.

Some of you made harsh comments about what I wrote about AIG. I said that AIG should sue the U.S. government and the Fed for saving it when it could have (more likely would have) gone under during the peak of the crisis in 2008.

Insights & Indictments reader Darrell said, "Enough. This is the most vile piece… I have ever read. Those people SHOULD have been allowed to fail. FULL bankruptcy! To borrow from the taxpayers to compensate the "managers" who steered us into this mess with bonuses, and then whine [when] the terms of the loan were too extreme is beyond hypocritical. Capitalism without risk is NOT capitalism. Something you would do well to learn. I am unsubscribing form this service."


Matt chimed in, "I'm with you. Acting like AIG is a victim of the big, mean Fed is preposterous. Maybe Shah and Alex Jones should take their baloney show on the road."

I'm shattered. I've been put upon. I feel victimized by these comments. Where's the safe harbor for journalists and bloggers? How can I be criticized so harshly and not feel victimized? Oh, the humanity!

Of course I'm kidding.

I subject myself to any and all comments when I exercise my freedom of speech. I keep a "Comments" section on my website so my readers can exercise their freedom of speech. I'm not a victim. I don't need any protection from free speech. Free speech is a two-way street.

The point is that I'm sick of the victim mentality. Are you fed up yet?

AIG played the game. It was not a victim of the Fed or the Government.

Banks played the game. They weren't the victims of regulation, the economy, or anything else.

No, they weren't victims. And they didn't create victims, either.

We'd like to see ourselves as their victims. It sure feels like that.

But, like I said, I'm sick of the victim mentality.

We let this happen. Maybe we didn't see it all coming, so we're not completely culpable. But, then again…

Darrell is right. "Capitalism without risk is not capitalism." There are no victims in capitalism. People, businesses, companies all fail. None of them are victims.

The opportunity to try comes with the risk of failure. That's the price.

You aren't a victim if you fail in capitalism; you're just a failed entrepreneur. Most of us get up, dust ourselves off and try again. We should be grateful for the opportunities available in this country.

That brings me back to AIG and the TBTF banks, or any other "protected class" of entrepreneurs. They have to be allowed to fail. A free society with America's unique brand of capitalism demands failure when and where it is warranted.

I wanted AIG to sue the Government and the Fed to open up the window to the back-room dealings that create protected classes of businesses in the first place. I want Americans to understand how that happens, why, and just who pays who for their protection.

Our American economic quandary is partly the result of less competition, not more competition. There are plenty of examples, but AIG and the big banks are the most obvious.

No company – in any industry, ever – should be allowed to get so big that it dictates prices or that its failure threatens the public good.

We need to stop coddling "victims" of the economy or regulation or their own doing.

And we need to stop being victims ourselves.

WE THE PEOPLE have to demand that all too-big-to-fail entities get broken up, so that the only victims in our economy are those who don't try to avail themselves of America's opportunities.

I'm glad we got that straightened out.

Related Articles and News:

Join the conversation. Click here to jump to comments…

About the Author

Shah Gilani is the Event Trading Specialist for Money Map Press. He provides specific trading recommendations in Capital Wave Forecast, where he predicts gigantic "waves" of money forming and shows you how to play them for the biggest gains. In Zenith Trading Circle Shah reveals the worst companies in the markets - right from his coveted Bankruptcy Almanac - and how readers can trade them over and over again for huge gains. He also writes our most talked-about publication, Wall Street Insights & Indictments, where he reveals how Wall Street's high-stakes game is really played.

Read full bio

  1. joseph gottfried | January 20, 2013

    if there is still aig the federal govt should take it over to releive taxpayers. all govt did is to pritect rich. jeg

  2. robert | January 20, 2013

    You are absolutely right. AIG should have been allowed to fail for the good of the country.
    The failure of the government to allow it is an offence against good government as well as an offence against capitalism. Sue.

  3. Iain | January 21, 2013

    Love your articles but I have to disagree with a lot of what you say in this one. Of course there are innocent victims eg the millions of people who have lost their homes and jobs because of the failure of government and central bank policies and the reckless behaviour of our banks. Joe public can't be expected to have a complete knowledge of the financial and political environment in order to make totally informed decisions about his/her financial situation. There are not enough hours in the day. Sometimes you have to rely on so called experts to do the right thing.

    • Counting Ace | January 22, 2013

      Government and central bank policies are set by people we elected. So, tell me again why you are a victim? You can keep believing you are a victim, but you voted for it, and you and your neighbors borrowed it.

      Did TBTF banks operate in bad faith? YES, they certainly did. Did ordinary Americans take loans they could not afford (or did not understand)? YES, they certainly did. Who is the originator of a liar loan? That's right, buddy….Joe Public.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Some HTML is OK