Start the conversation
Comment on This Story
Or to contact Money Morning Customer Service, click here.
This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.
Trusting Wall Street stock market predictions is really hazardous to your portfolio's health.
In particular, the annual Wall Street stock market predictions made by top strategists are so inaccurate, using a blindfold and a dartboard could do better.
These richly paid folks work for such financial behemoths as JPMorgan Chase & Co. (NYSE: JPM), Goldman Sachs Group (NYSE: GS), CitiGroup Inc. (NYSE: C), and Morgan Stanley (NYSE: MS). But few working Americans could get away with botching their jobs as badly as this bunch and still have jobs.
Collectively, the forecasts of these "experts" over the past 15 years have been off by an average of 14.7 percentage points a year.
That's worse than if they'd simply guessed the long-term average return of 9% every year. In that case, their forecast would have missed by an average of only 14.1 percentage points each year.
It's pathetic. But it gets worse.
Since 2005, independent economist Fritz Meyer has tracked the performance of Wall Street stock market forecasts that appear each December in Barron's. What he finds is consistently ugly.
For 2014, six out of 10 top strategists predicted the utilities sector would be among the worst-performing. By Dec. 31 it was the best, rising 24% on the year.
At the start of 2013, five of the 10 top strategists said the consumer discretionary sector would slump. Instead, that sector was the No. 1 performer, soaring 41%.
While those are the most egregious examples, failure is par for the course. In both 2011 and 2012, the strategists were wrong on six out of 10 sectors. Over the past nine years, Meyer has found much of the same.
"There is not one year in which, on balance, the strategists did well. They have consistently fallen far short of being able to beat the Standard & Poor's 500 with their sector calls," says Meyer in an article on his website.
But as awful as these Wall Street stock market predictions are, another element makes them downright dangerous – especially to retail investors…
MOMENTUM INVESTING
You can determine the current "hot sectors" by simply watching the behavior of specific sector ETF's which are driven largely by very large institutional investors. Relative Strength (RSI) tells all. Some sectors have done very well and institutional investors take large positions that often last for several years rather than months. Figure out where the big money is and ride the trends along, monitoring it quarter by quarter. What do the pundits know? Not much more than you or me, that's what.
Over the past 43 years of investing I have found various analysts who are consistently wrong about one or more specific things. For example, there is a high profile analyst who is almost always wrong about the price of oil. When he says the price is going down in 3 months, it's a good bet that it's going up in 3 months.
I beat the market almost every year by doing my own research, using common sense, and buying and holding dividend paying stocks and ETF's in indispensible industries such as utilities, apartment and warehouse REIT's, and health care providers.