This Monumental Industry Upheaval Will Give Us a Huge Opportunity

For almost 10 years now, hedge funds have been underperforming their benchmarks.

Even the biggest and historically best-performing funds are underwhelming investors, who aren’t sticking around just because managers are lowering their exorbitant fees.

They’re fleeing in droves for passive investing strategies like index funds.

But don’t count the Masters of the Universe out just yet.

Not only are hedge fund managers figuring out what’s causing their underperformance, the headlong rush by investors into index funds and exchange-traded funds could backfire, making hedge fund escapees wish they’d stuck to their guns.

Here’s why passive strategies have become so popular, how much money has been moved into them, and why that trend could turn out to be devastating…

Most importantly, here’s how everyday investors can benefit from what amounts to a monumental industry upheaval…

Overcrowding Doomed Hedge Funds

industryHedge funds have underperformed investor expectations and the benchmarks they’re supposed to beat since 2008. Only a handful of so-called hedge funds actually made money hedging the subprime mortgage meltdown in 2008, the rest of the industry took it on the chin.

More from Shah: How to Make a Killing... When Everyone Else Is Panicking

Still, fund managers got a break from investors who stuck around expecting better results in what looked like a tough market going forward.

They bet the wrong way.

From 2009 through the first quarter of 2016, hedge funds underperformed the S&P 500 (the most widely watched U.S. equity market index and benchmark) by 51 percentage points, according to Standard & Poor’s.

As a result, hedge funds have been losing investors and closing up shop. In 2015, according to Hedge Fund Research Inc. (HFR), more hedge funds shut down than any time since 2009, while 2015 also saw the fewest startups since 2008, before the credit crisis hit.

Some 530 funds were liquidated in the first half of 2016, the most since 2008. And hundreds of billions of dollars of investor money has flown out of funds, with another $51.5 billion withdrawn in the first nine months of 2016, says HFR.

Fund managers point to extraordinary market conditions, market manipulation, and their own inability to understand how global market conditions have changed and upended their traditionally successful strategies.

There’s plenty of truth there.

The Federal Reserve in the United States and central banks across the globe have manipulated interest rates to unprecedented, impossibly low levels, even into negative territory for almost $13 trillion of European and Japanese government bonds. On top of that, high-frequency traders move markets in mysterious, self-serving, and dangerous ways. The strangling of free market price discovery has upended strategies employed to profit from the normal ebbs and flows of free markets.

But the deeper truth, which managers readily acknowledge, is that the industry has become almost “commoditized” as the number of funds plying a lot of the same strategies has exploded. And that some of the same strategies that used to be successful are actually working in reverse and surprising traders in profound ways.

While overcrowding into the same strategies and the same stocks presents monumental event risk and liquidity issues for a wide swath of funds, some of the usual tried and true strategies funds employ are simply not working, and worse, backfiring.

The most recent example is so-called momentum trades, both long and short varieties.

It used to be managers who found good buying or shorting opportunities were followed into those trades as word got out about their research, their positions, or a significant enough move in the targeted stocks to draw other investors’ attention.

While medium- to longer-term holding periods, from months to quarters and even years, were the norm, short-term traders, algorithmic traders, countertrend traders, and trading desks trying to agitate stocks to trip stop orders have all radically changed the game.

After buying and enjoying positive momentum, backed by central banks’ reassurances they were in no hurry to raise rates, funds got sideswiped by the August 2015 10% sell-off. After taking their lumps and dumping positions, the market recovered and zoomed higher in the fall. But hedge funds were too scared to initially jump back in.

After solid gains, the momentum crowd came back onboard. Only to get mugged violently again in February 2016 by another 10% smackdown.

Meantime, funds looking to jump onto declining shares by shorting stocks that were headed south, in a bid to rake in profits as the market slid, got their heads chopped off.

[mmpazkzone name="in-story" network="9794" site="307044" id="137008" type="4"]

Funds got short Wynn Resorts Ltd. (Nasdasq: WYNN) in 2015, which was off 55%, but remarkably rose 35% in the first quarter of 2016. Range Resources Corp. (NYSE: RRC), another big hedge fund position, was also down 55% in 2015, and jumped 33% in early 2016. The same is true for Kate Spade & Co. (NYSE: KATE), down 45% in 2015 and jumped 45% in 2016’s first quarter.

The list goes on, and includes Dick’s Sporting Goods Inc. (NYSE: DKS) and Urban Outfitters Inc. (Nasdaq: URBN), both hedge fund shorts that reversed unexpectedly in 2016. It was enough to make managers scream and investors flee.

Get Our Best Wealth-Building Ideas: Money Morning’s top 5 investment reports to grow your money like never before are right here – and they’re absolutely free. Read more

Whether overcrowding is undermining hedge fund strategies or strategies themselves are backfiring, the net underperformance of funds with their high fees (relative to their indexed benchmarks with their negligible fees) is driving investors to passive investing strategies, namely indexed mutual funds and indexed ETF products.

The Flood Pushed Billions into Passive Strategies

Hedge fund investors fleeing to indexed mutual funds and ETFs already have lots of company.

In the three years ending Aug. 31, 2016, according to Morningstar, investors of all stripes pumped slightly more than $1.3 trillion into passive mutual funds and ETFs. Of that amount, some $250 billion was stripped from “active” mutual fund managers trying to beat their benchmarks.

While 66% of mutual funds are still active funds, that’s down 84% over the past 10 years. Between 71% and 93% of mutual funds in the 10 years (depending on the type of fund) closed or underperformed the indexes they were trying to beat, says Morningstar.

Passive investing is simply buying and tracking an index as opposed to paying a money manager to actively try and beat the market or an index. Over the past 40 years – since Vanguard Group’s John Bogle launched a passively managed S&P 500 index mutual fund – almost 30% of mutual and exchange-traded funds are now “index funds,” according to the Investment Company Institute. The ICI says that’s double their share a decade ago and eight times their share 20 years ago.

So… the trend’s your friend, right?

Sure it is. But the trend changes.

Passive indexing isn’t the answer a lot of its proponents want you to believe it is.

For one thing, stocks in any index can become overvalued relative to those outside it.

Index investors have little choice but to ride overvalued stocks down just like they did when hot technology indexes that drew in tons of money in the 1990s crashed violently in 2000.

Of course, most passive investing fans are huge fans of Warren Buffett because they consider him the ultimate passive investor.

But he’s not that at all.

While a dollar invested in Buffett’s Berkshire Hathaway Inc. (NYSE: BRK.A) between 1965 and 2015 grew an awesome 136 times as much as one dollar invested in the S&P 500, Buffett himself once admitted, “I’d be a bum on the street with a tin cup if markets were always efficient.”

In other words, he’s always trying to find value stocks and inefficiently priced shares, as opposed to just buying an index or the whole market.

The truth is, when active investing re-emerges and beats the pants off passive funds, probably starting right when the masses now rushing into indexed strategies head for the fire exits when investors not in those funds sell stocks, tanking passive funds whose managers have no choice but to go down with their ships.

Mass redemptions and a self-inflicted crash is going to make a lot of passive investors wish they followed a smart hedge fund manager.

Next time, I’ll tell you what hedge fund managers have learned and what the smart ones are doing now.

This Is the Best "Retirement Stock" of 2016… And the good news is, it's trading for "pennies." But it won't be for long… its revenue is set to surge 4,709%. Learn the details of this $5 stock today while it's still "on sale.” Read more

Follow Money Morning on Facebook and Twitter.

About the Author

Shah Gilani boasts a financial pedigree unlike any other. He ran his first hedge fund in 1982 from his seat on the floor of the Chicago Board of Options Exchange. When options on the Standard & Poor's 100 began trading on March 11, 1983, Shah worked in "the pit" as a market maker.

The work he did laid the foundation for what would later become the VIX - to this day one of the most widely used indicators worldwide. After leaving Chicago to run the futures and options division of the British banking giant Lloyd's TSB, Shah moved up to Roosevelt & Cross Inc., an old-line New York boutique firm. There he originated and ran a packaged fixed-income trading desk, and established that company's "listed" and OTC trading desks.

Shah founded a second hedge fund in 1999, which he ran until 2003.

Shah's vast network of contacts includes the biggest players on Wall Street and in international finance. These contacts give him the real story - when others only get what the investment banks want them to see.

Today, as editor of Hyperdrive Portfolio, Shah presents his legion of subscribers with massive profit opportunities that result from paradigm shifts in the way we work, play, and live.

Shah is a frequent guest on CNBC, Forbes, and MarketWatch, and you can catch him every week on Fox Business's Varney & Co.

Read full bio