Deflation Is Coming (and It's Not What You Think)

Update: This is an eerily prescient story from Shah. In the few months since we've published it, the wheels have come off the bull market (for the time being), and the danger of deflation looms larger and larger. Shah tells us what we need to do to come through unscathed. Here's Shah.

Email
    Text size
Author Image for Shah Gilani

Be careful out there.

The stock market rally that started in March 2009... The one that's taken us out of the Great Recession and to new highs... The rally that's driving sentiment indicators of people who benefit from rising financial assets directly, peripherally, or because they hope all boats rise with the market...

The rally has never been loved.

The thing is, equity markets don't need love to go twice as high from here, or three times as high in the next 20 years. If they get what else they need, they'll keep going higher.

We could be on the verge of a generational bull market. That's if deficit-plagued, interconnected global sovereigns deleverage and, at the same time, re-capitalize middle and rising classes by making "recourse-sound" capital available and simultaneously reconstituting entirely the notion of taxation.

Too bad the likelihood of that happening is somewhere between slim and none.

That's one reason why I'm an increasingly reluctant bull.

But there's another reason too.

And it has to do with deflation...

The other reason I'm increasingly reluctant is because governments have been running their printing presses nonstop.

The Most Unloved Bull in History Is Unloved for a Good Reason

Your high school science teacher always told you, "Correlation does not imply causation!"

But, as you can see, there is an extremely high (95%) correlation between the expansion of the Fed's balance sheet, and the  S&P 500's gains over the past for years and more. This can't be a coincidence.

[Click to enlarge]

What will happen if they don't stop? What will happen if they do stop?

Besides printing on account of deflationary fears, printing money globally to keep up with the Federal Reserve's massive quantitative easing (QE) experiment has been necessary to offset the Fed's intended consequences to depress the U.S. dollar.

Everyone wants to export their way out of slow growth. The U.S. is no exception.

But printing money - in an articulated policy - to pump up asset prices that benefit from low interest rates, a depressed dollar that benefits exports, and positive overseas revenue translations has been fueling asset price inflation for five years. It's also been leading a beggar-thy-neighbor campaign. Neither of those are sustainable.

When stimulus slows - or if it stops being effective - we'll see whether there's sufficient global growth and fiat trust to avoid deflation.

That's what central banks worry about, a lot more than asset bubbles.

So, is deflation coming? Yes and no.

It's not coming in the way most people think about it... at least, not at first.

Here's What Keeps Me Up at Night

The deflation that's coming first is coming to financial assets.

That's what I worry about. I worry about asset bubble deflation.

I worry that we're now 10% above where stocks, as measured by the Dow Jones Industrials, were at their 2007 peak. That just means we've made back all those credit crisis and Great Recession losses - theoretically - and may have started a new bull market.

And a 10% up-leg doesn't impress me when it's built on leveraging a zero interest rate policy.

So we just had a better than expected jobs report where 204,000 people landed jobs instead of the 120,000 analysts expected? So what if the previous two months saw slight upward revisions?

The unemployment rate still went up, not down.

The labor participation rate fell by 0.04% (to 62.8%) in October. That's the lowest rate since March 1978. It means fewer people are looking for work. More people are disaffected.

Speaking of analysts' revisions, so what if 70% of half the companies in the S&P who've reported earnings for the third quarter beat analysts' expectations? They all lowered them after last quarter to make them easier to beat. And they're lowering them again now because CEOs are guiding future expectations down again.

These days, revenues are rising a lot more slowly than earnings - if they're rising at all.

This begs the question: If the rate of change of revenue growth slows and earnings growth from buybacks (which by some measures could have added 40% to rising prices), productivity gains, and cheap debt financing slows down, aren't stocks fully priced? What's left for them to feed on?

So what that consumer sentiment is rising with stock prices? It's been rising because of rising home prices, too. How many stocks and how many homes do most people own? Oh, that would be a lot fewer than before the housing bubble broke and stocks crashed.

So what if volatility is at historic lows and seemingly resting comfortably there? That goes hand in hand with margin debt being at record levels.

This Party Won't Last Forever

It's all just one big party - as long as there's punch in the bowl and revenue to feed profits.

And that's where we are. We're at the intersection where asset price inflation (driven by stimulus) meets the real economy's ability to produce goods and services to sell to people who can afford them, as opposed to being redistributed to them.

Tapering, when it comes, will be scary.

Not that it's coming soon. But it is coming.

That's good news. Because there's going to be plenty of time, maybe a few more quarters if we're lucky, to get sufficiently defensive and put on strategic short positions. Do that now, just in case global growth isn't there to augment the soon-to-be-diminishing returns of quackitative easing.

The market has upward momentum. We're going into the holiday season where spending picks up. There's a better than even chance if the market moves higher a lot of institutional managers will buy up the winners to window-dress their fourth-quarter and full-year returns.

It's unlikely that Helicopter Ben will slow down QE right before he leaves office next year. He'll let his successor make her own policy decisions. Why would Ben risk wrecking the rally that he engineered when he's on his way out the door?

Over in my patch, we're adding selectively to positions that pay nice dividends, and we'll be happy to add more to those positions if the market falters. We're playing in the hot technology patch, and we're starting to put on some defensive positions in the Capital Wave Forecast portfolio too.

You don't have to love this market, but you do have to be in it. And you have to understand that, love it or hate it, the market can't go up in a straight line forever.

About the Author

Shah Gilani is the Event Trading Specialist for Money Map Press. He provides specific trading recommendations in Capital Wave Forecast, where he predicts gigantic "waves" of money forming and shows you how to play them for the biggest gains. In Short-Side Fortunes, Shah shows the "little guy" how to make massive size gains – sometimes in a single day – by flipping large asset classes like stocks, bonds, commodities, ETFs and more. He also writes our most talked-about publication, Wall Street Insights & Indictments, where he reveals how Wall Street's high-stakes game is really played.

... Read full bio