Share This Article

Facebook LinkedIn
Twitter Reddit
Print Email
Pinterest Gmail
Yahoo
Money Morning
×
  • Invest
    • Best Stocks to Buy
    • Stock Forecasts
    • Stocks to Sell Now
    • Stock Market Predictions
    • Technology Stocks
    • Best REITs to Buy Now
    • IPO Stocks
    • Penny Stocks
    • Dividend Stocks
    • Cryptocurrencies
    • Cannabis Investing
    • Angel Investing
  • Trade
    • How to Trade Options
    • Best Trades to Make Now
    • Options Trading Strategies
    • Weekly Trade Recommendations
  • Retire
    • Income Investing Guide
    • Retirement Articles
  • More
    • Money Morning LIVE
    • Special Investing Reports
    • Our ELetters
    • Our Premium Services
    • Videos
    • Meet Our Experts
    • Profit Academy
Login My Member Benefits Archives Research Your Team About Us FAQ
  • Invest
    • Best Stocks to Buy
    • Stock Forecasts
    • Stocks to Sell Now
    • Stock Market Predictions
    • Technology Stocks
    • Best REITs to Buy Now
    • IPO Stocks
    • Penny Stocks
    • Dividend Stocks
    • Cryptocurrencies
    • Cannabis Investing
    • Angel Investing
    ×
  • Trade
    • How to Trade Options
    • Best Trades to Make Now
    • Options Trading Strategies
    • Weekly Trade Recommendations
    ×
  • Retire
    • Income Investing Guide
    • Retirement Articles
    ×
  • More
    • Money Morning LIVE
    • Special Investing Reports
    • Our ELetters
    • Our Premium Services
    • Videos
    • Meet Our Experts
    • Profit Academy
    ×
  • Subscribe
Enter stock ticker or keyword
×
Join 100,000+ Like-Minded Investors Today
Twitter
Tags: Jason Simpkins

Speculators Feel the Heat as Demand for Tighter Regulation of Oil Contracts Rises

By Jason Simpkins, Managing Editor, Money Morning • July 8, 2009

View Comments

Start the conversation

Comment on This Story Click here to cancel reply.

Or to contact Money Morning Customer Service, click here.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Some HTML is OK

By Jason Simpkins
Managing Editor
Money Morning

The Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) may impose stricter limits on commodities speculators who are believed to be behind the main force behind wild swings in the futures markets over the past two years. The investigation has the support of politicians seeking greater price stability for the global economy and consumers, but traders argue that such restrictions will only reduce market liquidity and not necessarily prices.

CFTC Chairman Gary Gensler said his agency will hold a series of hearings from July through August to determine whether or not it should place new limits on energy futures contracts.

Right now, the CFTC sets limits on the amount of futures contracts in some agricultural products that can be held by market participants. But futures exchanges are free to determine what, if any, position limits should exist for energy futures.

The New York Mercantile Exchange (NYMEX) currently restricts oil traders to 10,000 net futures for any one trading month, and 20,000 net futures for all months. However, traders cannot exceed 3,000 contracts in the last three trading days of the spot month.

"This different regulatory approach to position limits for agriculture and other physically delivered commodities deserves thoughtful review," Gensler said. "It is incumbent upon the CFTC to ensure a fair and transparent price discovery prices for all commodities."

Speculators - specifically, large investment banks, such as Goldman Sachs Group Inc. (NYSE: GS) and Morgan Stanley (NYSE: MS), that build multibillion positions in futures and swaps in the commodities markets - are believed to be a big reason for the sharp fluctuation in oil and gas prices over the past two years.

Sign up for SMS so you never miss special events, exclusive offers, and weekly bonus trades.

As of last July, when oil hit a record-high $147 a barrel, financial investors had about $300 billion riding on indexes that track the value of futures contracts, according to the International Energy Agency (IEA). That's about four times as much as in January 2006.

Similarly, a sharp shift in the futures market this year helped oil prices rally about 115% to $73 a barrel in June from below $34 a barrel in February. Positions held on the New York Mercantile Exchange by investors who expected the price of oil to rise shifted from a net 11,000 short to 40,000 net long from May to June, as traders shifted their positions to reflect an improved outlook for the global economy.

That shift alone helped accounted for at least 20% of oil's price surge during that period according to the IEA.

"A lot of what we've seen in recent years has nothing to do with the underlying fundamentals of the market," Tom Bentz, a senior energy analyst at BNP Paribas Commodity Futures Inc. told Bloomberg News. "Something has to be done to reduce some of the speculation, no doubt about it."

In an opinion piece submitted to The Wall Street Journal yesterday (Wednesday) French President Nicolas Sarkozy and U.K. Prime Minister Gordon Brown said that the recent gyrations of the oil market defy the "accepted rules of economics," and called on regulators to take coordinated global action against market interference by speculators.

"The surge in prices last year gravely damaged the global economy and contributed to the downturn," the two statesmen said. "The risk now is that a new period of instability could undermine confidence just as we are pushing for recovery. Governments can no longer stand idle. Volatility damages both consumers and producers."

Brown and Sarkozy called on representatives of the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC), the IEA, and the Expert Group of the International Energy Forum (IEF) to work develop a shared analysis of future supply and demand trends and a price range that would be more consistent with fundamentals.

"The experts should also consider any measures that could be put in place to reduce volatility," they said. "Discussions should look again into the question of whether trading activity is amplifying erratic price movements."

Brown and Sarkozy said they would pursue the issue further at the meeting of the Group Eight nations in Italy this week.

Of course, not everyone is convinced that more regulation is the answer. 

Investment banks, such as Goldman Sachs and JP Morgan Chase & Co. (NYSE: JPM) "are the market makers," Michael Lewis, a partner at the Washington law office Paul, Hastings, Janofsky &Walker LLP told Bloomberg. "Those are the entities that have the huge positions. If the financial players, the banks, the hedge funds, et cetera, are limited to the number of trades they can take, it will lead to less trading. Less trading, I don't think necessarily leads to lower prices."

News and Related Story Links:

  • Bloomberg:
    Goldman, Morgan Stanley Threatened by CFTC Review
  • Money Morning:
    Oil Prices Due for a Short-Term Setback, Although Long-Term Outlook Remains Bullish
  • Wall Street Journal:
    We Must Address Oil-Market Volatility

Join the conversation. Click here to jump to comments…

Login
guest
guest
2 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
trackback
Global Slowdown And Plunging Profits Have "Big Oil" Companies Searching For Ways to Rebound
13 years ago

[…] low demand and rising supply of oil is catching the eye of regulators worldwide, who are applying the heat to speculators who are believed to be behind the main force behind wild swings in the futures […]

0
Reply
trackback
Traders Anticipate a Drop in Oil Prices as Supply Outruns Demand
13 years ago

[…] Money Morning: Speculators Feel the Heat as Demand for Tighter Regulation of Oil Contracts Rises […]

0
Reply


Latest News

June 5, 2023 • By Nick Black

This Tech Stock is Poised for Pick and Shovel Profits from the AI Revolution  

June 5, 2023 • By Garrett Baldwin

The (Horrible) Truth About the Vienna OPEC Meeting

June 5, 2023 • By Shah Gilani

earnings
The Best Commodities Stock to Buy Right Now
Trending Stories
ABOUT MONEY MORNING

Money Morning gives you access to a team of market experts with more than 250 years of combined investing experience – for free. Our experts – who have appeared on FOXBusiness, CNBC, NPR, and BloombergTV – deliver daily investing tips and stock picks, provide analysis with actions to take, and answer your biggest market questions. Our goal is to help our millions of e-newsletter subscribers and Moneymorning.com visitors become smarter, more confident investors.

QUICK LINKS
About Us COVID-19 Announcements How Money Morning Works FAQs Contact Us Search Article Archive Forgot Username/Password Archives Profit Academy Research Your Team Videos Text Messaging Terms of Use
FREE NEWSLETTERS
Total Wealth Research Power Profit Trades Profit Takeover Penny Hawk Trading Today Midday Momentum Pump Up the Close
PREMIUM SERVICES
Money Map Press Home Money Map Report Fast Fortune Club Weekly Cash Clock Night Trader Microcurrency Trader Hyperdrive Portfolio Rocket Wealth Initiative Extreme Profit Hunters Profit Revolution Quantum Data Profits Live Trading Alliance Trade The Close Inside Money Trader Expiration Trader Flashpoint Trader Darknet Hyper Momentum Trader Alpha Accelerators Weekly Profit Cycles Brutus Alerts Resource Traders Alliance

© 2023 Money Morning All Rights Reserved. Protected by copyright of the United States and international treaties. Any reproduction, copying, or redistribution (electronic or otherwise, including the world wide web), of content from this webpage, in whole or in part, is strictly prohibited without the express written permission of Money Morning.

Address: 1125 N Charles St. | Baltimore, MD, 21201 | USA | Phone: 888.384.8339 | Disclaimer | Sitemap | Privacy Policy | Whitelist Us | Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information

wpDiscuz