Subscribe to Money Morning get daily headlines subscribe now! Money Morning Private Briefing today's private briefing Access Your Profit Alerts

High-Frequency Trading is a Scam That is Crippling the Markets

Let me make this perfectly simple…

High-frequency trading is a scam. It should be outlawed.


Regulators, namely the pimps and panderers at the Securities and Exchange Commission, and the exchanges, all of them, are in on the game.

The game, known as HFT, isn't arbitrage, isn't fair, isn't consistent with the keeping of "fair and orderly markets," and so should be illegal.

In case you don't know, here are the rules of the game…

  1. Pay the exchanges to "co-locate" your servers next to their servers, at the locations where they house them (and rent space to you for that explicit purpose).
  1. Get access to quote information (what stocks are being "bid" for at what price and for how many shares, and what is the "ask" price and number of shares that sellers are trying to unload), and be able to place your own bid and ask quotes as fast as technologically possible.
  1. Get yourself a bunch of money to trade with. You'll need millions, so maybe form a partnership to raise money or partner with some banks that don't already have their own HFT desks, you know, the ones that want to hide what they do.
  1. Get yourself a few nuclear physicists, rocket scientists, and computer wizards to write algorithms that can read quotes on both sides of every stock to determine patterns, the depth of markets, and how many shares you can buy or sell and then sell or buy in a matter of less than one-hundredth or one-thousandth of a second.
  1. Get your computers to fire off fake bid and ask quotes all the time to see how that changes others' quotes, in anticipation that they might show how bad they want to buy or sell, and when you get to a place where you can fire trades to buy and sell, almost simultaneously, buy and sell or sell and buy however many shares you can to lock in a profit, no matter how small.
  1. Get busier and busier doing this more and more, because you're only working for a tiny profit on every trade, so do it to trade at least 3.5 billion shares a day, which is half of all the shares that the nation's 13 exchanges trade daily.
  1. Get faster computers and bandwidth and execution speed. If you reach some limit, go the other way. Figure out how to slow down other traders by gumming up the systems everyone uses; you know all the exchanges' systems that the SEC is supposed to be ensuring provides everyone fair and equal access to. Jam them all up with crazy amounts of fake quotes to increase "latency" (the time it takes to get from A to B for a computer, for other people, like mutual funds and pension peons) so you can head fake them and get your own trades off.
  1. Get rich gaming the system!

Look, it's not even a 12-step program. Just eight simple steps.

You can do it yourself. No one will stop you.

It's all legal, you know.

And at that Senate Banking Committee hearing on September 20, you know, the one where a former HFT guy named David Lauer came to testify that the game is rigged in "their" favor, and how he was pissed because he didn't have enough money behind him to buy enough new technology and pay off enough exchanges to get the faster access and cooler algos so he could make the millions he wanted, which is why he got into the business in the first place, yeah, that guy – even he said the game is rigged.

Lauer didn't say it was illegal. Of course, he wouldn't incriminate himself. And the Senators, they all nodded that the game did look rigged, but because it wasn't illegal, they'd have to think about what they heard and see who would now donate what to their campaign finance algorithms.

Personally, I feel sorry for him – Lauer, the tattletale. He's obviously not good enough at what he was doing to compete. Poor fellow. I think he cut class the day they taught the lesson on "creative destruction." At least it looks like he made it to the lecture on tactical assault practices that obviously included "subtle carpet bombing" and "scorched-earth techniques."

But I digress.

There's nothing redeeming about high-frequency trading. Nothing.

Maybe I should write a real article on why it's a bunch of crap and who's really behind it?

Oh, I've done that. I did it two-and-a-half years ago, here at Money Morning.

Guess it's time to do it again. Look for it in your mailbox on Monday.

Related Articles and News:

Join the conversation. Click here to jump to comments…

About the Author

Shah Gilani is the Event Trading Specialist for Money Map Press. He provides specific trading recommendations in Capital Wave Forecast, where he predicts gigantic "waves" of money forming and shows you how to play them for the biggest gains. In Zenith Trading Circle Shah reveals the worst companies in the markets - right from his coveted Bankruptcy Almanac - and how readers can trade them over and over again for huge gains. He also writes our most talked-about publication, Wall Street Insights & Indictments, where he reveals how Wall Street's high-stakes game is really played.

Read full bio

  1. Daniel Victor | October 14, 2012

    You just have to be a long-term investor,buy if stocks are cheap enough,then sell them if they become overvalued.Leave firm limit orders and don't move the limits without careful consideration.Then those guys can't really hurt you.

  2. Eric Coish | October 14, 2012

    Yes, HFT is even more unfair than shorting (which no one seems to complain about), to say nothing about naked shorting, which happens all the time and appears to be condoned by the SEC and other
    "regulatory" agencies. The basic problem with shorting is that someone can sell shares which I paid for, make a profit, ruin the price of my shares in the process and walk away without paying me a cent. That unsavory practice, along with HFT, should be outlawed. Mind you, they'll spend millions going after the little guy, but turn a blind eye to the big money interests who have rigged every market.

  3. linda carpenter | October 14, 2012

    I would think the SEC would get on this. in view of the fact that there`s so much animosity toward wall street and thier shenanagans now-

  4. Richard Lefcourt | October 14, 2012

    Shah: I agree. HFT is even worse than leaked insider info since it goes on every minute of every day.

  5. Zoe | October 15, 2012

    Shah, surely there are enough parties adversely affected by HFT that they can bring enough pressure to bear to have it made illegal? Pension fund managers, fund managers, advocates for the "little guy"?

    Is there any kind of a lobby on this?

    Thank you for the article.


  6. A Donald - - Not The Donald | October 15, 2012


    Yes, do it again! Who is behind the HFT's; and, who is profiting most from this?

    I'd say the time is drawing near to get the best Hackers in the Business to do a little, "night-time," work.

    Tell the Story!\


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Some HTML is OK