The Dumbest Tech Company Idea I've Ever Heard

Michael A. Robinson

When you've knocked around Silicon Valley for as long as I have, you're bound to hear your fair share of really bad ideas.

And I just heard a bad idea for a tech company that tops them all.

On June 16, The Wall Street Journal suggested that Apple Inc. (Nasdaq: AAPL) drop its Mac desktop computer division.
Specifically, it ran a column suggesting that Apple flush its line of Mac desktop computers.

That idea makes some of the biggest "loser" pitches I heard during my days as an advisor to venture-capital funds sound like polished gems of genius.

First off, slashing its Mac division would sap nearly $6.9 billion – that's 9% – from Apple's top line. Does taking a 9% pay cut sound like a good idea to you?

But that's just the "simple" reason for not following the Journal's advice.

Today, I want to show you exactly why Apple needs to protect tech investors and their hard-earned money from this horrible advice.

And I'll tell you what to do if Team Tim Cook even considers such a move…

The Tech Company's Creative Department's Secret Weapon

At first glance, the Journal's advice might seem smart.

After all, PC makers have been under pressure for years – starting even before the rise of smartphones and tablets.

In late 2004, International Business Machines Inc. (NYSE: IBM) sold off its PC business because of declining profits.

And just two years ago, we saw the worst decline in PC shipments ever – from a 6.9% drop from 88.7 million units shipped in the fourth quarter of 2012 to 82.6 million units in fourth-quarter 2013.

So, from that survivor standpoint alone, Apple's Mac has to be considered the single most successful PC ever.

First released in January 1984, the Mac was the first mainstream PC to feature a graphical user interface – those are the icons on your PC's screen you use to navigate through your computer – and a mouse.

In no time, the Mac turned the creative and publishing industries upside down. Suddenly, advertising agencies, magazines, and newspapers – and later, websites – could use a single computer for just about everything.

To this day, the Mac remains the standard of excellence in just about every creative field, from animation and publishing to website design and engineering.

So, for The Wall Street Journal to suggest Apple should "kill off the Mac" shows an utter lack of understanding of the critical role this device plays in the lives of millions of professionals.

Not to mention Apple's financials. Consider that the Silicon Valley legend makes more profit on Macs than the top five PC vendors combined.

And like I said, Apple sold 5.5 million Macs last year, bringing in $6.9 billion, or 9% of overall sales.

I'm not making this up. This next statement is a direct quotation from the article:

"This would be a crazy thing to say for any other company, but Apple doesn't need this revenue."

They're right. That is a crazy thing to say…

Join the conversation. Click here to jump to comments…

Michael A. Robinson

About the Author

Browse Michael's articles | View Michael's research services

Michael A. Robinson is one of the top financial analysts working today. His book "Overdrawn: The Bailout of American Savings" was a prescient look at the anatomy of the nation's S&L crisis, long before the word "bailout" became part of our daily lexicon. He's a Pulitzer Prize-nominated writer and reporter, lauded by the Columbia Journalism Review for his aggressive style. His 30-year track record as a leading tech analyst has garnered him rave reviews, too. Today he is the editor of the monthly tech investing newsletter Nova-X Report as well as Radical Technology Profits, where he covers truly radical technologies – ones that have the power to sweep across the globe and change the very fabric of our lives – and profit opportunities they give rise to. He also explores "what's next" in the tech investing world at Strategic Tech Investor.

… Read full bio