Oil Prices Are Tightly Correlated to Stocks – But for a Different Reason Than Before

Oil prices haven't been this tied to stock performance in nearly three decades.

Right now, the correlation between Brent crude oil prices and the S&P 500 is at its highest level since 1990. From Jan. 4 to Jan. 25, their correlation was 0.97 – higher than any month in the last 26 years. A correlation of 1 means crude oil and the S&P 500 move perfectly in step with each other. A correlation of -1 means they move in completely opposite directions.

The connection between oil prices and stock prices is usually tighter during recessions. It topped out above 0.8 during the peak of the financial crisis in 2008.

But the 0.97 correlation between the two right now is unusual considering oil prices aren't crashing nearly as hard as they were in 2008. West Texas Intermediate (WTI) – the U.S. benchmark – cratered 77% between July 2008 and December 2008 alone. WTI has crashed 64.4% in 2014-2015, but that's over the last 18 months.

Most analysts blame the correlation on investor fear of a U.S. market collapse.

"Currently, big swings in oil prices may be forcing some investors to sell stocks simply because they measure risk in their portfolios by looking at volatility across a range of assets," The Wall Street Journal reported earlier this week.

Energy commodities have certainly been one of the most volatile asset classes of 2016 so far. WTI oil prices are down 13% this year and currently trade at a 12-year low of $34 a barrel. Natural gas prices have fallen 7.6% since Dec. 31. Meanwhile, the S&P 500 is down 5.6% over the same period.

While much of the sell-off in both commodities and stock prices certainly stems from fear of a domestic market crash, there's one foreign factor that's having an even greater impact than oil on investors' sentiment toward stocks.

Here's the biggest reason why crude oil and the stock market are in lockstep right now…

Why Oil Prices Are Tightly Correlated to the Broader Market in 2016

The strong link between oil prices and the stock market is a direct result of China's ongoing meltdown.

The Shanghai Composite Index – the bellwether index for China's economy – has crashed 22.6% over the first 20 trading sessions of 2016. It currently sits at its lowest level since November 2014. Meanwhile, the Hong Kong-based Hang Seng Index has fallen 10.2% to its lowest level in more than three years.

As the second-largest oil consumer in the world, China's struggling economy is rattling investors. The problem became clear in November when oil imports fell by 218,000 barrels per day to a 20-month low. Overall demand that month hit 732,000 barrels per day – down 9.9% from the same month in 2014.

But China's role as the world's second-largest economy is what's sending the broader U.S. market lower. The country's massive growth and appetite for raw materials around the world has an incredible influence on the global economy. After the Shanghai Composite fell from its peak last June, markets around the world have experienced a domino effect of sell-offs.

"Right now it is the fear of a Chinese slowdown that is spooking the market," said Barnabas Gan, commodity analyst at the Singapore-based investment bank OCBC, to MarketWatch. "Most of the selling is based on emotions and panic."

Alex McGuire is an associate editor for Money Morning who writes about energy. Follow him on Twitter for the biggest oil and gas updates.

Like us on Facebook: Money Morning

China Just Made the Gutsiest Move of the Entire Financial Crisis: By scrapping its one-child rule, China's created a massive investment opportunity. This policy reversal will drive an historic shift in production and consumption that will double the size of China's economy by 2035. The time to act is now. Here's how to align your money for maximum profit…

Related Articles:

• The Wall Street Journal: Oil, Stocks at Tightest Correlation in 26 Years