Bitcoin Taxes Will Create Nightmares for Investors - What to Do

Painful Bitcoin taxes will bite many unsuspecting investors next year unless they take action to mitigate the impact before the end of the year.
This is especially true for the 2017 tax year, in which extraordinary gains have been the norm.

Even with the recent 32% drop from an all-time high of just over $5,000, the Bitcoin price stands at about $3,400 - a 252% gain for the year.

Bitcoin taxesOther cryptocurrencies have had much bigger gains. The Ethereum price has soared from $8 on Jan. 1 to $225 now - a gain of 2,700% in less than nine months. The price of Ethereum peaked at $400 in June.

Meanwhile, the initial coin offering (ICO) craze meant a lot of new cryptocurrencies entered the market, dozens of which racked up mammoth gains in a matter of weeks or even days.

The total market cap of all cryptocurrencies, including Bitcoin, was about $18.2 billion at the start of the year. Today it's $113 billion, an increase of 520%.

While racking up such huge gains feels great, those profits are taxable.

And next April, the IRS won't be looking the other way...

Why the IRS Will Take Bitcoin Taxes Seriously This Year

The IRS first issued guidance on how to treat Bitcoin gains in 2014. That document declared Bitcoin to be an intangible property, making it plain that gains in Bitcoin or any other cryptocurrency are taxable and must be reported.

The IRS knows people are making heaps of money from cryptocurrencies, and it is determined to collect taxes on those profits.

Since then, the IRS has grown increasingly concerned that cryptocurrency investors are failing to report their profits. That's why the IRS filed a civil petition against Coinbase last November, compelling the cryptocurrency wallet and exchange company to turn over customer records.

In March, in new court documents related to the Coinbase case, the IRS said an investigation had revealed that just 807 taxpayers had reported any Bitcoin transactions in 2013, 893 in 2014, and 802 in 2015 - despite steadily rising cryptocurrency usage.

Coinbase has more than 10 million customers. Although Coinbase operates in 32 countries, it's likely the majority of those customers live in the United States.

In July, the IRS amended its request to just those customers that had conducted at least $20,000 worth of business between 2013 and 2015.

Related: How to Buy Bitcoins - Your Guide to Digital Profits

No matter how this case gets resolved, it tells us one thing loud and clear: The IRS knows people are making heaps of money from cryptocurrencies, and it is determined to collect taxes on those profits.

Unfortunately, a lot of gray areas remain when it comes to Bitcoin taxes. Here's what we know - and the best ways for investors to proceed...

How to Report Your 2017 Bitcoin Taxes

The first thing to note is that choosing not to report cryptocurrency gains is a bad idea. You might get away with it - but you might not.

With some exceptions like Monero and Dash, cryptocurrencies aren't as anonymous as people think. And the IRS knows what it is doing.

The Daily Beast reported last month that the IRS has enlisted the services of a company called Chainalysis to help it "trace the movement of money through the Bitcoin economy."

If you have made a lot of money - tens of thousands or more - and that money starts showing up in your bank accounts, the banks are required to report it to the IRS.

And if you're caught, the penalties are severe. You can get slapped with a negligence penalty of 20%, as well as a substantial understatement penalty of 20% for understating your income by 10% or more.

It's best not to tempt fate.

Must See: Marijuana stocks are seeing triple-digit gains, and the next wave of wealth is coming. Learn how you could turn a small $100 stake into a fortune. Read more...

But figuring out what you need to report, and where to report it, is no easy task. The IRS has yet to clarify numerous issues.

Let's look at some specific circumstances...

  • Bitcoin You Held: Bitcoins you bought in 2017 or earlier years, but did not sell or trade, are not subject to taxation on any gains made.
  • Bitcoin You Mined: Few people are mining Bitcoin in the United States now because of the high cost of the mining rigs. But mined Bitcoin counts as income and must be reported in the year you earned it. The value of the Bitcoin is the Bitcoin price at the time it was mined. So if you mined Bitcoin in 2010 or 2011, you should have reported it then. It's unlikely the IRS will fuss over that since Bitcoin was worth only a few dollars back in those years.
  • Bitcoin You've Received or Earned: If someone gave you Bitcoin (lucky you!) or if you earned some in exchange for work performed, that must be reported as income. This means strict record-keeping, because the value is based on the price of Bitcoin when you received it. Again, this is taxed as income, not capital gains.
  • Bitcoin You Sold or Traded for Other Cryptocurrencies: Gains or losses from selling Bitcoin are treated like capital gains. If you bought five Bitcoin last year at $600 ($3,000 invested) and sold them at $4,000 this year for $20,000, you have to pay taxes on your $17,000 gain. It works the same way as stock investments.

Bitcoin priceIf you bought Ethereum, Litecoin, or any other cryptocurrency with your Bitcoin, that counts as a "taxable event," which means you must pay taxes on the gains. You need to calculate the difference between what you paid for the bitcoins and their value when the exchange for another crypto took place.

By the way, this is true for all cryptocurrency trading. If you used Ethereum to invest in an ICO, you owe capital gains tax on the difference between what you paid for that Ethereum and how much the ETH was worth when you invested in the ICO. If you used Litecoin to buy Monero, same thing.

Unlike brokerages, who send you a convenient statement of your annual transactions for tax purposes, the record-keeping for cryptocurrency trading is all on you.

  • Bitcoin Cash: Here's where things get really squirrelly. Bitcoin Cash, a separate version of Bitcoin, was created by the Aug. 1 hard fork. Anyone who held Bitcoin as of Aug. 1 received an equal amount of Bitcoin Cash. Not everyone was able to get access to their Bitcoin Cash - those who had Bitcoin in Coinbase accounts must wait until Jan. 1.

The IRS has offered no guidance on this, but is likely to treat your newfound Bitcoin Cash as income. So you need to report it even if you don't control it. In his Green Trader Tax blog, CPA Robert A. Green recommends using $266 (the initial market price) as the Bitcoin Cash price and reporting it as "Other Income." So if you owned five Bitcoins on Aug.1, you need to report the as income the value of five Bitcoin Cash units - $1,330.

If you sold or traded your Bitcoin Cash - which many people did - any gain from that is capital gain that must be reported separately. So if you sold them at $500 in the weeks after the hard fork, our hypothetical five BCH would result in a capital gain of $1,170 (the $234 gain over the basis cost of $266 times five).

All that said, here's what Bitcoin and cryptocurrency investors need to do before Dec. 31...

What Bitcoin Investors Can Do to Protect Themselves

[mmpazkzone name="in-story" network="9794" site="307044" id="137008" type="4"]

One piece of good news: If you use Bitcoin for relatively small transactions, you might not trigger capital gains taxes. I say "might" because this common-sense break is just a bill in the House of Representatives now.

If it becomes law, the bill will create a de minimis exemption for cryptocurrency purchases with a value below $600. It's similar to an existing exemption for purchases made with foreign currencies.

Otherwise, Bitcoin investors can take several steps now to avoid a nasty surprise next April.

  • Get your records in order: As noted above, no one will be sending you tidy, IRS-ready tax forms for inclusion with your return. The more activity you've had buying, selling, and trading cryptocurrencies, the earlier you want to get started on this.
  • Look for Losses Elsewhere: If you have some big losers in your portfolio, now's the time to dump them. Capital gains losses you take on these stocks can offset some of the huge gains you've made in cryptocurrencies, thus reducing what you owe.
  • Set money aside: Don't spend all of your cryptocurrency windfall. Make sure you stash some away so that you'll be able to pay Uncle Sam next year. And if you have already spent it, you have six months to save up. You don't want to face a $5,000 tax bill with an empty bank account.

Want to Invest in Weed and Don't Know Where to Start? Well over half of the country already has marijuana legally available in some form. Eight states plus our nation's capital have made it completely legal to anyone over the age of 21. And the marijuana stock market is preparing to take off. Watch this short video and see whether jumping on this moon-bound stock rocket is right for you.

Follow me on Twitter @DavidGZeiler and Money Morning on Twitter @moneymorning, Facebook, or LinkedIn.

About the Author

David Zeiler, Associate Editor for Money Morning at Money Map Press, has been a journalist for more than 35 years, including 18 spent at The Baltimore Sun. He has worked as a writer, editor, and page designer at different times in his career. He's interviewed a number of well-known personalities - ranging from punk rock icon Joey Ramone to Apple Inc. co-founder Steve Wozniak.

Over the course of his journalistic career, Dave has covered many diverse subjects. Since arriving at Money Morning in 2011, he has focused primarily on technology. He's an expert on both Apple and cryptocurrencies. He started writing about Apple for The Sun in the mid-1990s, and had an Apple blog on The Sun's web site from 2007-2009. Dave's been writing about Bitcoin since 2011 - long before most people had even heard of it. He even mined it for a short time.

Dave has a BA in English and Mass Communications from Loyola University Maryland.

Read full bio